Resisting Change or Preserving Value

M10 1

Views: 195

All Rights Reserved

Copyright © 2010, Common Ground Research Networks, All Rights Reserved

Abstract

This paper examines the way in which members of a long-term care facility construct a concept of “resistance” to change to account for the inability of workgroups to integrate new people and new ideas into their practice. After introducing the research questions and qualitative methods (including a blend of ethnography and case study methods), the paper explains how workgroup members have created a knowing and learning dynamic that allows them to cope with the uncertainty of their environment and to complete the numerous tasks that comprise their heavy workload. The paper then shows that the primary focus of this workgroup is seen as the maintenance of the status quo, which leads some observers to label them as “resistant to change.” This resistance, however, is a construct that permits change agents to hold others accountable for their inability to introduce needed reforms and improvements. The paper concludes that local resistance to change can sometimes be motivated by a workgroup’s desire to preserve the value that they currently experience in their work. For example, caregivers might resist the addition of new tasks to their workload in order to preserve the time needed to provide psycho-social support to patients.