Broken Images – Returning the Gaze to the Spectator: Ethical Reading in Havarie by Philip Scheffner (Germany, 2016) and El Mar La Mar by Joshua Benetta and J. P. Sniadecki (United States 2017)

Abstract

My study focuses on documentary filmmakers who choose to position their camera as a critical, self-conscious eye examining conventions in the media governing the representation of suffering. The two films are part of a growing group of documentaries that avoid direct images and focus on alternative, almost abstract image. They relate to an ethical crisis concerning the image – a crisis of figurability. Questions concerning the ethics of representation grew more emphatic with new technology that enabled the photographing of horrors unfolding in the twentieth century (Saxton 2008). The films ‘handle’, injure and undermine the visual image, while the voice assumes a significant role. The faceless and bodiless voices in the films want us to be haunted by their absent presence; where the gaze failed, the voice is what calls people to awake, they force one to reflect on one’s blindness and deafness. Derrida leans back to the Greek mythology and notes that blindness is often the price to pay for insight- and calls it ‘revelatory blindness’.(1990-1)) Libby Saxton also reads blindness as an ethical stance and speaks of ’vigilant blindness’. Emanuel Levinas in his ethical philosophy intertwines the ethical term ‘face’ (l.e., visage, which is not necessarily visual) with ‘speech’ (l.e., dit, which is not necessarily verbal) and seeks a moment of epiphany through face or language, a moment which impels us to listen and arouses our ethical responsibility toward the Other (Levinas [1960] 1995).

Presenters

Anat Tzom Ayalon
Student, Doctoral Degree , The Steve Tisch School of Television and Cinema, HaMerkaz, Israel

Details

Presentation Type

Poster Session

Theme

The Image in Society

KEYWORDS

CRISIS OF FIGURABULTY, TRAUMA, ETHICS, FACE, VOICE

Digital Media

This presenter hasn’t added media.
Request media and follow this presentation.