Understanding the Epistemology and Metaphysics of Student Plagiarism: It's Much Less An Ethical Issue Than You Think

Abstract

Student plagiarism is generally misunderstood as a primarily ethical issue. In this study, I present a view that student plagiarism is instead primarily an epistemic issue, and that properly appreciating the nature of student plagiarism as distinct from other kinds of plagiarism reveals that the difficulties it causes are of a significantly different nature than typically conceived. This misconception of the nature of student plagiarism leads to inappropriate and unconstructive policies and reactions from educators, and distracts from more useful ways to address it. A discussion of specific examples of typical academic-integrity policies and whether they fruitfully address plagiarism, or are inadvertently unproductive, is also included.

Presenters

Kirk Mc Dermid
Chair, Philosophy, Montclair State University, New Jersey, United States

Details

Presentation Type

Paper Presentation in a Themed Session

Theme

Learning in Higher Education

KEYWORDS

Academic Integrity, Plagiarism, Student Assessment, Deception, Expertise