Journals as Gatekeepers: Structures, Policies, and Practices to Build Trust

Abstract

Publishing endorses research and therefore allots journals a gatekeeper function in the knowledge economy. Which structures, policies, and practices can assist a journal in this gatekeeping function? In a case study measures taken by a journal to strengthen its position among similar journals, distinguishing itself as a gatekeeper to be trusted and supported, is examined. The measures taken include, among others, the diversifying of reviewers and restructuring of the editorial board. Comparing the new measures implemented within the journal structures, policies and practices with other journals and results found in the literature, recommendations could be made regarding best practices for improving the gatekeeper function of a journal.

Presenters

Lyzette Hoffman

Details

Presentation Type

Paper Presentation in a Themed Session

Theme

2021 Special Focus: Critical Thinking, Soft Skills, and Technology

KEYWORDS

Knowledge economy; Building trust; Editorial board; Reviewer diversification

Digital Media

Downloads

Journal Gatekeepers - Hoffman (mp4)

Journal_gatekeepers_HoffmanL.mp4

Journal Gatekeepers - Hoffman (pptx)

Journal_gatekeepers_HoffmanNew.pptx