The Recruiting Trap that Kills Diversity: Root Causes, Empirical Evidence, and Steps to Overcome the Recruiting Trap

Abstract

A large body of empirical research shows how prejudice and cognitive biases affect the hiring decisions of recruiters. People who are likewise and match certain norms are favored. Laws, regulations, and cooperate policies have limited success in preventing these biases. We propose a phase-gate recruiting process as a way to reduce or overcome the recruiting trap. A foundational principle of this framework is that there is not a single-best candidate that need to be identified and recruited, but that there are many candidates that will perform great depending on the situational circumstances. The resulting recruiting process comprises of three gates: the qualification gate, the motivation and integrity gate, and the diversity gate. This enables corporations to overcome biases and foster organizational diversity leading to a more talented, engaged, and diverse workforce.

Presenters

Thomas Seemann
Professor, Baden-Württemberg Cooperative State University (DHBW), Germany

Melanie Seemann
Hochschule Furtwangen University

Details

Presentation Type

Paper Presentation in a Themed Session

Theme

Organizational Diversity

KEYWORDS

Diversity, Recruiting, Cognitive biases