Vatican Mediation and the Beagle Channel Conflict: A Bottle of Wisdom, a Barrel of Prudence, and an Ocean of Patience

Abstract

Chile and Argentina signed a Treaty of Peace and Friendship in Vatican City in 1984. The result of six years of papal mediation, this treaty marked the end of a territorial dispute with roots over a century old. A successful resolution of conflicting territorial claims was by no means guaranteed at the outset, and hostilities threatened to break out during the negotiations. Nevertheless, the Treaty of Peace and Friendship resolved territorial issues and navigation rights, and Chile and Argentina remain at peace today. Contrary to predictions based on mechanisms borrowed from a theory of mediation and peacekeeping from Smith and Stam, a biased and powerless mediator credibly facilitated the exchange of the “wrong” kind of information and, without resorting to the “right” leverage, successfully formulated a peace treaty. Salient characteristics of the Vatican’s mediation include confidentiality, institutional patience, information management, and flexibility.

Presenters

Brian Muzas
Assistant Professor and Director, the Center for United Nations and Global Governance Studies, School of Diplomacy and International Relations, Seton Hall University, New Jersey, United States

Details

Presentation Type

Online Poster

Theme

Civic and Political Studies

KEYWORDS

Mediation, International Conflict, International Relations, Religion, Religious Cultural Heritage, Vatican

Digital Media

This presenter hasn’t added media.
Request media and follow this presentation.