Produced with Scholar
Icon for World War I

World War I

Year 9 In-Depth History Study

Learning Module

Abstract

Students investigate key aspects of World War I and the Australian experience of the war, including the nature and significance of the war in world and Australian history.

Keywords

History, Chronology, Perspectives, Causes, Impacts, Gallipoli, Propaganda, Conscription, Women, Anzac Legend.

Knowledge Objectives

As a result of completing this learning module based on the Australian Curriculum: History, students will be able to:

Historical Skills

Chronology, terms and concepts

Use chronological sequencing to demonstrate the relationship between events and developments in different periods and places (ACHHS164)

Use historical terms and concepts (ACHHS165)

Historical questions and research

Identify and select different kinds of questions about the past to inform historical inquiry (ACHHS166)

Evaluate and enhance these questions (ACHHS167)

Identify and locate relevant sources, using ICT and other methods (ACHHS168)

Analysis and use of sources

Identify the origin, purpose and context of primary and secondary sources (ACHHS169)

Process and synthesise information from a range of sources for use as evidence in an historical argument (ACHHS170)

Evaluate the reliability and usefulness of primary and secondary sources (ACHHS171)

Perspectives and interpretations

Identify and analyse the perspectives of people from the past (ACHHS172)

Identify and analyse different historical interpretations (including their own )(ACHHS173)

Explanation and communication

Develop texts, particularly descriptions and discussions that use evidence from a range of sources that are referenced (ACHHS174)

Select and use a range of communication forms (oral, graphic, written) and digital technologies (ACHHS175)

Historical Knowledge and Understanding

Depth studies

There are three depth studies for this historical period. For each depth study, there are up to three electives that focus on a particular society, event, movement or development. It is expected that ONE elective will be studied in detail. A depth study will constitute approximately 30% of the total teaching time for the year. The content in each depth study elective is designed to allow detailed study of specific aspects of this historical period. As part of a teaching and learning program, depth study content can be integrated with overview content and/or with other depth study electives.

World War I

Students investigate key aspects of World War I and the Australian experience of the war, including the nature and significance of the war in world and Australian history.

World War I (1914-1918)

An overview of the causes of World War I and the reasons why men enlisted to fight in the war (ACDSEH021)

The places where Australians fought and the nature of warfare during World War I, including the Gallipoli campaign (ACDSEH095)

The impact of World War I, with a particular emphasis on Australia (such as the use of propaganda to influence the civilian population, the changing role of women, the conscription debate) (ACDSEH096)

The commemoration of World War I, including debates about the nature and significance of the Anzac legend (ACDSEH097)

1. Expert Groups: The Great Powers in 1914

For the Student

Learning Intention: To develop your understanding of what makes a great power.

Think-Pair-Share: What makes a country powerful? Draw own your own knowledge of powerful countries today.

Discuss as a class.

Each group will be given a data set that details the Empire's power.

  • Germany
  • Britain
  • France
  • Russia
  • Austria - Hungary
  • Italy
  • Japan
  • Turkey/Ottoman Empire
  • United States

Read through the information and take dot points about the country.

Prioritise the dot points to the most important 8.

Share you dot points with your group.

Comment: Share one new fact you learned in this jigsaw. Read other students' facts and add one more fact if you can without repeating what another student added.

Fig. 1: Map of Europe in 1914, showing the great powers and their alliances.

For the Teacher

 

In this update, students draw on their prior knowledge and experiences as well as readings to understand what makes a country powerful. Possible answers:

  • military strength
  • government
  • land mass
  • resources such as land, minerals, food, textiles and people
  • economy/wealth
  • geographic position
  • Colonies

Resource:

'The Great Powers before 1914 - data set sof information.

The following comes from the MyRead website.

Expert Jigsaw

  1. The activity is characterised by participants within a cooperative group each becoming expert on different aspects of one topic of study.
  2. Before presenting and teaching to the cooperative group, students for Expert Groups, comprising of individuals from different cooperative groups who have the same assigned topic.
  3. Together, expert partners study their topic and plan effective ways to teach important information when they return to their cooperative groups.
  4. One way of teaching is for the expert group to display their information on paper.
  5. Or participants can return to their cooperative groups and teach all members of their groups as they are now experts.

It is important that the teacher works out both groups before hand, so that all groups have a mixture of abilities.

2. Why Go to War?

For the Student

Learning Intention: To explore reasons why a country might go to war.

Look at the powerpoint of the leaders in Europe in 1914. With a partner, identify who they are. Refer to the internet to verify your answers.

Leaders in 1914 in Europe

Comment: Imagine you are one of the world leaders in 1914. War clouds are gathering. In your opinion, why would you go to war? 

Include examples from the previous activity from your country's perspective.

Fig. 2: "The Chain of Friendship", an American cartoon from 1914 depicting the web of alliances, captioned, "If Austria attacks Serbia, Russia will fall upon Austria, Germany upon Russia, and France and England upon Germany."

For the Teacher

Background information: World Leaders in 1914:

  • Germany: Kaiser Wilhelm II
  • Britain: King George V
  • France: President Raymond Poincare
  • Russia: Tsar Nicholas II
  • Austria - Hungary: Emperor Franz Joseph I
  • Ottoman Empire: Sultan Mehmed V
  • NOTE: At the outbreak of World War One President Woodrow Wilson declared the U.S neutral.

Potential answers:

  • power
  • belief in certain ideologies
  • increasing wealth
  • hatred for another race
  • nationalism
  • reinforcing superiority

3. Causes of the War Cartoon

For the Student

Learning Intention: To describe the short term and long term causes of the First World War.

Watch 2-3 of the following youtube clips which describe the causes of World War 1. With a partner, discuss the reasons they give for the beginning of the war.

The 4 M-A-I-N Causes of World War One in 6 Minutes

Epic History: World War 1 (12.09)

Black Adder: How did World War 1 begin (2.29)

5 Major Treaties & Alliances in the Build Up to World War One (4.54)

Look at the cartoon below. Think-Pair-Share: What are your initial thoughts of the cartoon? What does it depict? List what causes of the war does it illustrate. Put each of the causes from the youtube clips and the cartoon into the following table.

Long Term Causes Short Term Causes
   
   

One way to remember these causes is MANIA B (Militarism, Alliances, Nationalism, Imperialism, Assassination and Balkans).

Comment: Share one new fact you learned in this jigsaw. Read other students' facts and add one more fact if you can without repeating what another student added.

Fig. 3: A German cartoon from 1914 showing the lay of the political land as seen from the German perspective at the outbreak of World War One. As the text below the picture states, Germany and the Austro-Hungary Empire defend “blows from all sides”, particularly from the east in the form of a huge snarling Russian face. To the right of the image a banner declares that 10% of the proceeds of the map’s sale will go toward the Red Cross.

 

For the Teacher

This update focuses on the causes of WW1. Students may need to watch the videoclips more than once to understand the information that is presented.

Resources: 'Causes of the War cartoon'

Cartoon Answers:

Long Term Causes Short Term Causes
Militarism/Arms Race  
Alliances  
Imperialism The Balkans War
Nationalism Assassination of Franz Ferdinand

Prompting questions (optional):

  • What incidents increased the feeling of tension and suspicion?
  • Why is the Balkans shown as a bomb and what is the significance of the fuse?
  • Where are the Balkans?
  • Which incident actually lit the fuse?
  • Why is the alliance system seen as a balancing act?
  • Do you think the cartoon accurately shows the situation in Europe by 1914? Explain.

4. Causes of the War Overview (Reading Map)

For the Student

Learning Intention: To identify the main facts in an information text about the causes of the First World War.

Reading Map

Step One: Draw the layout of the textbook pages on a blank piece of paper and record any headings, subheadings and pictures on to the sheet of paper. It should look like a series of boxes.

Step Two: Record 5 key points from each section of text under each heading and sub-heading. Describe the pictures and cartoons.

Step Three: Share with a partner and compare information. Check if you have covered the key points of each section. Amend if necessary.

Overview of The Causes of World War One

Comment: From all the information you have now read and viewed, what do you think is the main cause of World War 1. Give one reason for your opinion. Read other students' comments to see how your opinions and reasons are the same and different.Then comment on 1-2 other students' comments, explaining why you agree or disagree with them. Start with @Name so they know you are commenting on their comment.

Fig. 4: Reading Map

For the Teacher

Causes of the War overview (reading map)

'Humanities Alive 4, ‘The Causes of World War I’, pages 4-5'

Reading Map

What is it? Students create a framework to be used for noting key points from the text as they read.

5. MAIN Cause and Effect

For the Student

Learning Intention: To understand the links between the causes and effects of World War 1.

One important skill a historian needs to develop is to see the connections between causes and consequences. Complete the following chart. Once consequence is provided. Add as many more as possible to each cause. Work collaboratively and use the internet to find out more information.

Cause  Consequence
Nationalism Sense of unity among people of a country
Imperialism Importance of transport routes between a country and its colonies
Militarism More employment in munitions industries
Alliances More negotiations between countries.

Comment: What do you think was the main reason the war started - Militarism, Alliances, Nationalism, Imperialism, Assassination or Balkans? Read other students' comments and comment on 1-2, building on their ideas and/or explaining why you agree/disagree with them. 

Fig. 5: Imperialism: A shocked mandarin in Manchu robes in the back, with Queen Victoria (United Kingdom), Wilhelm II (Germany), Nicholas II (Russia), Marianne (France), and Emperor Meiji (Japan) discussing how to cut up a king cake with Chine ("China" in French) written on it.

For the Teacher

Cause and effect

Possible answers:

Nationalism

  • Hatred amongst nations e.g. The French hated the Germans.
  • Assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand. A Serbian nationalist killed him.
  • It made the races ruled by Turkey (such as the Romanians and the Bulgarians) and by Austria-Hungary (such as the Serbs) want to be free to rule themselves.
  • Alliances
  • Patriotism
  • Feelings of superiority

Imperialism

  • Advanced the wealth of the European powers
  • Border disputes such as the Boer War
  • Tensions between countries.
  • Envy of other powers greater wealth through larger colonies and influence.

Militarism

  • Feelings of hostility between nations
  • Armies and navies were greatly expanded
  • Development of mobalisation and attack plans such as the Schlieffen Plan.
  • International rivalry
  • As one country increased its armies, so all the otehrs felt obliged to increase their armed forces to keep the 'balance of power.'

Alliances

  • The countries of Europe thought the alliance system would be a deterrent to war; in fact it obliged them to follow each other to war.
  • It lead to confrontations
  • False sense of security
  • It led to countries being more aggressive because they had the backing of another country.

6. Digital Gallery Walk: Causes of the War

For the Student

Fig. 6: An example of a poster on the front page of a magazine. It shows how part of militarism was the build up of naval power

Learning Intention: To understand the function of one cause in contributing to the outbreak of war. 

You will be placed into groups that will research a short term or long term cause of World War One.

The groups are:

  • Militarism (Arms Race)
  • Alliances
  • Imperialism
  • Nationalism
  • Assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand
  • Balkans War

In your group, read all of the available information and create a poster which includes the key dot points and how  this idea/event lead to war? (Don't forget to reference the information).

Digital Gallery Walk

Create an Update: Scan/photograph your image. Then post your group's poster and a short rationale, explaining the poster. Then read other groups' updates and comment on the success of their posters in explaining the MANIA B concepts. Also ask any clarifying questions which a member of the group should answer for you by starting with @Name.

For the Teacher

The purpose of this activity allows students to become experts about one particular cause of the First World War and share this knowledge with their group. This activity allows students to get through a large amount of factual information as they develop their understanding of how one cause contributed to the outbreak of war.

Resources:

  • Militarism (Arms Race)
  • Alliances
  • Imperialism
  • Nationalism
  • Short Term Effects (Assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, Balkans War)

Teaching Tip:

Instead of a digital galley walk, display the posters in the room and studnets move around the "gallery, using post it notes to ask clarifying questions that the group needs to answer. This will help them to further their understanding of the topic.

7. Assessment: Essay: Causes of the War

For the Student

Learning Intention: To apply what you have learnt about the causes of World War 1.

Essay Question: 'What were the 3 main factors for the outbreak of the World War One?'

Write a persuasive essay about the main causes of World War One. You MUST include at least 3 main factors as to why the world plunged into world war in 1914.

EXTENSION: Include a fourth cause of World War One.

Rubric: Once you accept the "Work Request" in your Notifications, read through the rubric so you understand what is expected of you in this essay task.

Comment: Do you have any questions about how Scholar works? Make a comment in this update. If you think you have an answer to another student's question, please answer it - be sure to name the student you are replying to in your comment by starting with @Name.

Fig. 7: Symbols like the British lion and the German eagle were an ever-present part of pre-war nationalism

For the Teacher

Long Term Causes:

  • Alliances
  • Imperialism
  • Arms Race (militarism)
  • Nationalism

Short Term Causes

  • Assassination of Franz Ferdinand
  • Balkans War

Highlight these key points from the rubric:

  • Students must use relevant evidence such as statistics and quotes from primary and secondary sources to strengthen their essay. At least include one quote \ statistics should be included in each body paragraph.
  • Don't forget STRUCTURE.
  • Write strong P and C sentences.
  • Include a bibliography.

NOTE: Students will have 2 lessons in class to conduct research for their essay. They will have 2 lessons in the computer lab. They may work on it at home. At the end of the second lesson, the essay must be submitted.

Project Rubric

 

8. KWL: World War One

For the Student

Learning Intention: To consider what you have already learned and what you would like to find out more about World War One.

Turn your book to landscape and divide it into 3 columns, Know, Want and Learn (KWL).

Fill in the first column and second columns.

Do not fill in the last column, Learn. This will be completed at a later date.

K: What do you KNOW about World War 1? W: What do you WANT to KNOW about World War One? L: What have you LEARNED about World War One?
     
     
     
     

View the images of the World War One as you are watching them, add to the know (K) column or want (W) column.

Images of World War One (Powerpoint file)
World War One Pictures (Publisher file)

Comment: Share one idea from your "W" column so we have a class list of all that the class is interested in. Read through and comment on any that you would also like to find out more about. Start with @Name so the student knows you are commenting on their comment.

Fig. 8: German soldiers in a railway goods wagon on the way to the front in 1914. Early in the war, all sides expected the conflict to be a short one.

For the Teacher

This update summarises what students have already learned to date as a segway into the next phase that focuses on Australia's involvement in the war.

KWL: World War One

NOTE: In Update 12 students will come back to reflect in the learning (L) column.

9. The Archduke has been Assassinated - Now What?

For the Student

Learning Intention: To identify the specific events that led to the outbreak of war in 1914.

Look at a timeline showing the sequence of events that led to the outbreak of war in 1914. Illustrate these events on the map of Europe, using colours, lines and any other appropriate symbols. For example, where nations allied, colour them in the same colour; where there is talk of military mobilisation, draw lines showing the direction and location that troops from one country would be heading towards.

Note you will have to identify the countries and some of the countries no longer exist under those names with those borders. Use this map to guide you.

Map of Europe in 1914

Useful Resources: 10 Events that Led to World War I

The Great War (PBS)

Comment: Why do you think that Some of the countries on the map in 1914 no longer exist? Read through other students' comments, ask questions, explain why you agree/disagree with their ideas, and/or elaborate on their information.

Fig. 9: As described by contemporary Spanish magazine El Mundo Gráfico: "The moment when the Austrian archdukes, following the first attempt against their lives, arrived at the City Council (of Sarajevo), where they were received by the mayor and the municipal corporation."

For the Teacher

This update enables students to put specific events that led to the war into perspective. It complements their understanding of the MANIA B concepts.

Students should complete the map activity in groups of 2-3, researching to identify names of countries and also recording timeline events on the map.

10. Australia Declares War

For the Student

Learning Intention: To understand why Australia became involved in the First World War.

Watch the clip from Australians At War, Episode 2 "Who'll come a fighting the Kaiser with me" below.

With a partner, record dot points as you discuss:

i. What ideas did this society hold about duty, pride and the Empire?

ii. What main similarities and differences existed in the Australia on 1914 and Australia today?

iii. Why did Australia need to prove itself to Britain?

iv. What does the statement ‘it was harder not to enlist than enlist’ tell you about Australia at the time?

Look at  how the Australian Government reacted to war. You will be assigned one section to read and take notes and then share in your group.

Comment: Using the information from the sources, list one reason why the Australian government committed Australia to involvment in Britain's war in 1914. Also add one reason against Australia going to war. Read other students' comments, adding more reasons, elaborating on the information, and asking clarifying questions.

Media embedded October 5, 2016

 

For the Teacher

Australia declares war

The comment in this activity should generate a class list of facts that students have learned.

Resources: 

Clip from Australians At War, Episode 2 "Who'll come a fighting the Kaiser with me"

Gallipoli and the Anzacs - Unit 1 - Australia is at war - 1914

11. Why did Men Enlist?

For the Student

Learning Intention: To understand the reasons for and against Australia going to war.

There were various reasons and motives as to why men signed up to fight in 1914. List the reasons why men went so readily to war.

Create the table in your books and look at the  quotations from letters and diaries of men (and one woman) who enlisted in the Australian Army. 

Reason  Evidence
   
   

Comment: If World War III was to break out tomorrow would you go? Why / Why not? Your best friend has decided to do the opposite to you. What reasons would you give to persuade them to do what you would do? Read through other students' comments and comment on 1-2 that you think provide good reasoning. Explain why.

Fig. 11: Australian World War 1 recruitment poster

 

For the Teacher

This update clarifies reasons why men went to fight in 1914.

Some possible answers:

  • Sense of adventure
  • Patriotism to Britain (wanted to fight for their country)
  • 'Over before Christmas.'
  • Joy of War (people wanted to fight)
  • Comradeship
  • Women thought they were cowardly if they didnt sign up.
  • Friends and family signed up

Dont want to fight

  • Not our fight
  • 'Conscentious objectors'
  • 'pacifists' who believed it was wrong to kill other people
  • Some trade unions were against the war because they were concerned that there would be a shortange of workers.

Resources

Gallipoli and the Anzacs - Unit 1 - Australia is at war - 1914  Print so students can access relevant sections of the pdf.

12. Where did Australians Fight During World War One?

For the Student

Learning Intention: To understand where and how Australian soldiers fought in World War 1.

Read through 'Where did Australians fight during World War One' (attached below)

On a blank map of the world locate all of the places where Australians fought. Annotate each location with the name of the place and what happened there.

Reflection:

  • What have you learned?
  • What has surprised you?
  • What place interested you?
  • Add comments to your KWL in Update 8.
Where did Australians fight during World War One
Map of World

Now you know where Australians fought, read through the following information about How World War One was fought. Read First World War 1914-1918 (Australian War Memorial). With a partner, make notes as you discuss:

i. How was World War One the same and different from preceding wars?

ii. Did new technology actually extend the war?

iii. Why do you think that the use of poison gas was banned under the Geneva Protocol while the use of other types of weapons was not?

iv. What were the advantages and disadvantages of new developments in communications? 

v. Read and discuss British Empire's first shot in Great War, fired in Victoria, commemorated. Did this surprise you? Why/why not?

Comment: Create an Update where you report your research about new technologies that were developed and refined during WWI. Describe the weapon, and how it was developed and used. You can add images, videos and website links. Explain whether this technology prolonged or shortened the war. Add anything else about the technology that is interesting. Read other students' updates and comment on one any that you think are interesting, explaining why. 

Fig. 12: Australian 9th and 10th battalions, Egypt, December,1914

For the Teacher

Resources:

  • World Map
  • Atlas
  • 'Where did Australians fight during World War One?'

Other resource: How and where World War I was fought? from Oxford Big Ideas page 244 - 246. 

In the comment, studnets can create their own updates so they can use the multimodal tools to report their research on new technologies.

13. Gallipoli: Brother in Arms

For the Student

Learning Intention: To understand the importance of Gallipoli to Australia's identity.

Explore websites about Gallipoli, the landing, the nature of the campaign, soldiers' experiences, Anzac day and the links between the Anzacs and Australian Identity. You could start with the ABC 3D Documentary site about Gallipoli.

Think-Pair-Share-Predict: Look at the title of the documentary, Gallipoli Brother in Arms. Write down as many words or phrases as possible that you think relate to the topic.

Who has the most words?

Watch Andrew Denton’s Gallipoli: Brother in Arms and as you are watching write down anything that interests you or think is important. Put it on a post it note. One idea = one post it note.

After watching the documentary read through the post it notes and create an affinity diagram. What categories does the information you gathered fall into?

Comment: Why do you think Gallipoli is so important to Australians? Considering the websites and the documentary, do you think that the messages they give are mainly pro or against war, or is it both? Give reasons for your opinion. Read other students' opinions and comment on 2-3, explaining why you agree or disagree with them.

Fig. 13: ANZAC Truce, 24 May 2015

For the Teacher

NOTE:

Think - 1 minute

Pair - 2 minutes

Share - Record as many words or phrases as you can in 2 minutes.

Resources:

  • post it notes
  • DVD - Andrew Denton's Gallipoli: Brother in Arms

Possible affinity categories:

  • the landing
  • the nature of fighting
  • the living conditions
  • Australians attitudes towards the Turks

Study guide: 'Gallipoli: Brother in Arms'

Enough Rope's Gallipoli: Brother in Arms Study Guide

There are a number of activites that centre around Gallipoli. 2015 was the 100 year anniversary of that campaign and more resources were developed.

The aim of the following lessons is for students to understand the landing, the nature of the campaign, soldiers experience, Anzac day and the links between the Anzacs and Australian Identity.

Following the Gallipoli lessons you might move onto the Western Front or discuss the commoration of Anzac day.

 

14. Gallipoli

For the Student

Learning Intention: To undertand why the ANZAC legend is still significant today.

Some have suggested that the Peter Weir film,Gallipoil (1981), played an important role in the revival of interest in the Anzac legend.

View the film and discuss why the film may have had this impact. Refer to specific examples in the film (scenes, characters, incidents, symbols and music). You will only watch part of the film in class

Comment: Write 2 PEC paragraphs answering the following questions:

Gallipoli was a defeat, yet it is commemorated each year. Why do you think this is the case?

What is the Anzac legend and why is it still significant today?

Media embedded October 5, 2016

 

For the Teacher

Gallipoli directed by Peter Weir

This film is very long so only show part of it so students can view it as homework.

15. Background to the Conscription Debate

For the Student

Background:

The initial enthusiasm which greeted the outbreak of war subsided quickly as the conflict dragged into its second year. The high cost of life at the Dardanelles, the news of suffering and hardship, the apparent inability to break the enemy, as well as the privation and restrictions at home, destroyed the idealised vision many had of the fighting.

November 1915: Hughes announced that Australia’s overseas forces would be increased to 110,000 men, but by 1916 the British General Staff set the figure of 16 500 per month. The number of volunteers had begun to decline by 1916, so in Hughes’ opinion, Australia had no alternative other than to introduce conscription (compulsory enlistment) for overseas service.

Look at the graphs and table describing the number of soldiers enlisting in Australia. Why did enlistment peak? Why was enlistment dropping?

Background to the conscription debate

Read through the letter Prime Minster Billy Hughes sent out to all Australians in December 1915. 

The Call to Arms Billy Hughes

With a partner, record dot points as you discuss:

  • Why do you think fewer men were enlisting voluntarily in December 1915 than had been at the start of the war?
  • What emotions does Mr Hughes play on to urge men to enlist? Do you think it is effective? Why?
  • What reasons does Mr Hughes advance to support his argument for more volunteer enlistment? Do you feel they are logical and rational?
  • What does he mean by the comment “…the Australian armies would long ago have been camping in Constantinople”?

Comment: Imagine that you are a young man in 1915 and you receive this letter from Billy Hughes. Can you explain how and why you would respond? Comment on other students' responses too.

Fig. 15: Recruitment poster

For the Teacher

Resources: 'Australian Enlistment figures'

Teacher notes:

Australian population 1914-1918: four million

416, 809 Australians enlisted for service in the First World War, representing 38.7% of the total male population aged between 18 to 44.

Enlistment peaked in July 1915 due to the Gallipoli campaign.

 

16. The Blood Vote

For the Student

Learning Intention: To analyse anti-conscription perspectives in Austrealia during World War One

Read through the poem 'The Blood Vote' by W.R. Winspear, issued during anti-conscription campaign, 1917.

Fig. 16: The Blood Vote

With a partner, record dot points as you discuss the following:

  • In your own words describe the dream of the women.
  • How do you think that this poster would have affected people’s attitudes?
  • What emotions does this poem play on to make people want to vote against conscription? Do you think it is effective? Why?
  • What does this mean?

'Why is your face so white, Mother?

Why do you choke for breath?

O I have dreamt in the night, my son,

That I doomed a man to death.'

Create a Venn diagram about the similarities and differences between the letter written by Billy Hughes and the poem.

The Blood Vote

Comment: What is the most effective way to persuade people - through the letter or the poem? Give reasons for your opinion. Then comment on 1-2 other students' comments, explaining why you agree or disagree with them. Start with @Name so they know you are commenting on their comment.

For the Teacher

 This Update enables students to compare and contrast two very different perspectives in the conscription debate.

 

17. Are you For or Against Conscription?

For the Student

Learning Intention: To analyse different perspectives to the conscription debate during World War One.

View the conscription posters at WW1 Propaganda Posters. What do you notice about them?

Draw a table in your book which has a column for and against conscription.

What arguments did the posters present for and against consription?

Explore The Conscription Debate website and read about and listen to the audio which gives perspectives from the different sections of Australian society.

Add more ideas to your table with arguments for and against.

Assessment Task: Speech

Take on the role of an Australian during World War One. This person is either for conscription or against. Some roles are very clear cut such as a member of the trade union who was against conscription. Others could go either way such as a mother/father whose son died at Gallipoli.

  • A mother/father whose son is fighting on the Western Front (you support conscription because you want others to go and support your son).
  • A mother/father who lost her son fighting at Gallipoli
  • An 17 year old Australian boy
  • Recent immigrant from Britain (recent immigrants from Britain vote in favour of conscription; loyalty to Britain was strong and Britain had introduced conscription for its armed forces).
  • A farmer (generally supported conscription; sales of primary products to Britain at guaranteed prices for the duration of the war reinforced their pro-British stance).
  • A soldier fighting on the Western Front
  • Daniel Mannix, Archbishop of Melbourne
  • Member of the trade union
  • Veteran from the Boer War
  • Member of the Labor Party – Billy Hughes supporter

As you prepare your 2-3 minute speech, think about how you will become your person, think about the language they would use and persuade the listeners to feel the way you do.

Read through the rubric. If you have any questions, need clarification or have something you think should be added, write it on a post it note so that it can be discussed as a class.

Conscription Roles
Conscription Speech Rubric

Comment: If you were alive in 1916, how would you vote in the Conscription referendum? For or Against? Why? Explain your answer.

Fig. 17: Anti-conscription propaganda

 

For the Teacher

Students analyse websites exploring a range of perspectives about conscription and then take on the role of an Australian during World War One, presenting a speech, detailing how they feel about the issue of conscription. This is an argumentative text.

18. The Experience of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People During World War 1

For the Student

Learning Intention: To understand the discrimination faced by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander soldiers during and after World War One.

Background:

When war was declared in August 1914, Aboriginals and Torres Strait Islander men were barred from enlisting. The Defence Act 1903 had provided for a compulsory military training scheme that did not include Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander men. This, together with a constitution that gave the federal government responsibility for defence but not for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People, effectively meant that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people could not enlist. This lasted until 1917, when the need for meow soldiers led to a revision of the Defence Act.

About 400 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander men served in World War I, some from the very earliest days, although the exact number will never be known. This is partly because the army did not record the race of enlistees, but also because Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People often claimed to be Indian, Italian or Maori. There were no segregated units.

In your group, explore:

Indigenous Australians at War

Indigenous Australian Servicemen

Aboriginal service during the First World War 

The Stafford Brothers online exhibition

Comment: How do you think you would feel if you volunteered to fight for your country but were rejected because someone objected to being close to you? Why do you think Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander soldiers returning home may have felt discriminated against when they were unable to secure blocks of land under the Returned Servicemen's settlement scheme?

View the following clips for more information.

Media embedded October 5, 2016

 

Media embedded October 5, 2016

 

For the Teacher

There are many other resources available online that studnets can be encouraged to serach and view.

Other Resources:

  • Message Stick - The Forgotten
  • Message Stick - Lest We Forget
  • My Place Episode 10 - Bertie (probably more suited to year 7/8)

NOTE: What was the Returned Servicemen's settlement scheme?

19. The Experience of the Australian Soldiers and Nurses

For the Student

Learning Intention: To develop your research skills as you learn about the experiences of Australian soldiers and/or nurses during World War One.

Research the experience of a soldier or nurse who served in World War One. Include primary sources like service records, letters and diaries (if they are available). You might have a relative that you would like to research.

Information you must include in your assignment is:

  • Describe your soldiers or nurse? E.g. Age, what they did prior to the war, where they grew up, family etc. 
  • Why did soldiers/nurses go to war?
  • What training did soldiers/nurses receive?
  • Where did Australian soldiers fight? (Where was your soldier or nurse stationed?)
  • What were their living conditions like?
  • How did they view the enemy?
  • What happened to your soldier/nurse after the war? 

If you cannot find out specific information about your person, you must write about him/her, using general information about soldiers and nurses during World War One

Develop at least 5 extra questions you would like to answer in your research. 

Here are some websites that you could use.

Gallipoli and the Anzacs
Australians in World War 1
The Great War
Australia and World War 1: The Rush to Enlist
Smythe Index: Letters from Bert
Dadswell Family Website

Creative Presentation:   

Present your research in an interesting way such as:

 

  • Create a diary for your soldier
  • Write a series of letters the he or she might have sent
  • Prezi / ppt / video
  • Write his or her biography

Look at an example of a creative response - The Great War and Me: Nurses' Experiences by Michaela Taylor.

Include a bibliography and reference any resources that you use.  

Choose one website you used and evaluate the reliability of the website by completing the "Evaluating Online Resources" worksheet. Consider the website's trustworthiness, purpose, accuracy and ease of use. Once you have downloaded and completed the worksheet you can submit it by going to the class community and submitting it as a "Share with Admin" in the pull down menu above the community avatar.

Evaluating Online Resources
Assignment sheet: The experience of war

Comment: Share one important thing you learned about assessing the reliability of online resources. Why is it important?

Media embedded October 6, 2016

For the Teacher

The purpose of this activity is to develop students' research skills and to learn about an individual soldier or nurse, perhaps someone in their family history.

This task is challenging students to look beyond an easy Google search and look for a wide range of materials, and to develop their skills in assessing and analysing a wide range of sources.

This topic lends itself to primary source research, has appeal – relevant; might link to family history; and also is linked to personal stories which students may connect with.

Add Assessment Rubric.

20. Plastic Surgery then and Now

For the Student

Learning Intention: To understand the importance of plastic surgery during World War One.

Read the following information about plastic surgery during World War One.

How do you fix a face that’s been blown off by shrapnel? (BBC)

Facial plastic surgery advanced by WW1 tragedies

Pioneering plastic surgery records from First World War published

Make a list of similarities and differences between plastic surgery then and now.

Comment: Make a list of similarities and differences between plastic surgery then and now.Keep adding ideas, making sure you read what other studnets have added so you don't repeat any.

Media embedded October 6, 2016

For the Teacher

RELIEF LESSON: Plastic surgery then and now

Resources: Complement the online links with "Plastic surgery then and now" from Oxford Big Ideas History 9, pages 280 - 281.

Potential answers:

Unprecedented injuries:

1. Answers might include: shrapnel wounds; poison gas burns; disfigured faces and bodies due to artillery shells; and shattered bones and amputated limbs due to machine guns.

2. Being afraid of going out in public; difficulty meeting new people; dfficulties reconnecting with old friends and family members; feelings of shame about their appearance; difficulties in finding a job; and difficulties functioning normally.

A new kind of surgery

1. Skin grafts, flap surgery and staged grafts.

2. His open wound would likely be come infected, which may have killed him; he would have struggled with feeling of chame and embarrassment, impacting on his life; he would have struggled with basic bodily function, such as eating and drinking; and he would have lacked confidence in his engagement with others.

'normal' to 'perfect'

1. The nature of the wounds suffered by many soldiers in WWI would have prevented them from leading a normal civilian life after the war ended. The surgical techniques developed to treat these wounds, and allow the soldiers to live relatively normal lives, began to be used purely cosmetic purposes in the second half of the 20th century.

2.Similarities: plastic surgery can still be used to allow people with terrible wound to live a relatively normal life; many of the techniques used in modern plastic surgery were pioneered by Dr Harold Gillies during WWI.

Differences: many plastic proceedures such as butt cheek implants, are undertaken for purely cosmetic purposes; plastic surgeons are highly paid professionals rather than experimental surgeons breaking new ground.

21. Weaponry and Animals at War

For the Student

Learning Intention: To understand the importance of animals in warfare and theimpact of new technologies in weaponry.

Think Pair-Share: What animals were used during World War One and what was their purpose? 

Complete the survey quiz.

Look at some of the following Youtube clips and weblinks:

World War 1 American Legacy (WWI Animals)

Media embedded October 6, 2016
Media embedded October 6, 2016

 Behind the news: Animals at war

 
Media embedded October 6, 2016
Animals at War

Complete the table on old methods of warfare vs new technologies in weaponry that emerged during World War One.

Old methods of warfare New technologies
   
   

Comment: There are many websites and youtube clips about animals in war and new weaponry. Find one that interests you and summarise its main points. Include a link so other students can look it up too. Read 2-3 comments by other students and comment on how advancements in technology have made animals in war obselete. Start with @Name so the student knows you are commenting on their comment.

For the Teacher

Start the Animals at War True or False Quiz'

1. False, World War One, in which 10 million soldiers died, also resulted in the deaths of 8 million military horses. 

2. True

3. True

4. True

5. False.  Pigeons played a vital part in World War One as they proved to be an extremely reliable way of sending messages. Such was the importance of pigeons that over 100,000 were used in the war with an astonishing success rate of 95% getting through to their destination with their message.

6. True

7. True

8. True

 Old methods of warfare  New technologies
soldiers fighting on foot
swords
single shot rifles
horse back
air craft
U-boats
tanks
barbed wire
long range artillery
machine guns
poison gas

 

22. The Commemoration of World War 1

For the Student

Learning Intention: To understand why the ANZAC Day tradition is commemorated.

With a partner, select 2-3 articles from Reports from Gallipoli

With a partner, make notes as you discuss the following questions:

  • Why has Anzac Day become more important to Australians than Australia day?
  • What do the articles have to say about the Australia and Australians?

Read Ashmead-Bartlett's description of the landing at Gallipoli: The Battle of the Landing,25 April – 3 May 1915

  • What does Ashmead-Bartlett's description of the Anzacs add to the interpretations of Australia and Australians?
  • Do you believe that Ashmead-Bartlett's description is reliable? Give reasons for your decision.

Comment: If you ask a handful of Australians how they feel about ANZAC Day, you will likely hear many conflicting answers. Some believe this memorial day glorifies war, while others seem to feel it’s entirely appropriate to do so. Others feel that ANZAC Day is a sad and sobering reminder of the horrors of war. What is your opinion? Give reasons. Comment on the opinions of 1-2 other students, explaining why you agree/disagree with them.

Fig. 22: The monument of Simpson and his donkey at the Australian War Memorial commemorates the ANZAC tradition.

You might also like to view a Last Post Ceremony that commemorates the lives of soldiers.

For the Teacher

Students explore a range of articles, making links between ANZACs and the Australian identity.

23. Memorial Box

For the Student

Learning Intention: To theorise and research objects from World War One

  • Put on the gloves provided.
  • Look, pick up and discover the items from World War One.
  • Ask your teacher questions about items.
  • Pick 2 items that interest you and discuss with the class.

Choose one item from the Memorial Box that interests you. Read the accompanying descriptor if you have one.

What questions does this item make you think of for further research? Think about:

  • Where the object was made.
  • Who may have made the object.
  • What the object is made out of.
  • What the purpose of the object is. Other uses?
  • Effectiveness?

Record the questions you develop and then begin researching the answers to your questions.

Create an update where you include what you found out about your object. Add images and other multimedia that you find in your research. Look at 1-2 updates of other students and comment on anything that you found interesting, ask questions, and add information that you know about the object.

Fig. 23: World War 1 Memory Box

For the Teacher

In this Update students draw on what they have learned throughout the unit to theorise information about objects in an Australian War Memorial Memory Box. Memorial Boxes are available across Australia.

Memorial Boxes are an engaging learning resource for any age. Filled with real and replica uniforms, equipment and artefacts, these versatile packs can be used to invigorate classroom lessons, inspire historical investigation, and add meaning to commemorative activities. 

NOTE: Prior to setting up classroom, teachers need to take pictures of all of the items on display so that students can refer to them when they are completing the assessment task.

Instructions:

  1. Set up room with the artifacts. Put descriptors with the artifacts that have them.
  2. Students are to wear gloves to handle the items.

 

24. Research and Creative Response

For the Student

Learning Intention: To apply what you have learned in a researched creative response.

Where does your item that you have just researched fit in with these themes of World War One?

  • Women at War
  • Soldiers at War
  • Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander experience
  • Conscription
  • The home front
  • The legacy of World War One

Once you have decided which theme your object fits into, develop 5 questions based around the theme of war to further research.

NOTE: Three of these questions will guide your research for your creative response.

They need to be approved by your classroom teacher before you proceed to research.

Use class time to research your question, prepare for the presentation and complete a creative response. 

Possible creative responses:

  • Create a diary for a soldier, nurse or child during the war.
  • Write a series of letters a soldier or nurse might have sent.
  • Create a dorama of a battle field or trench.
  • Create a radio (podcast) or film re-enactment of a news broadcast describing the war effort
  • Create a new uniform for the solidiers.

Comment:  Reflect on what you have learned in this module through a 3-2-1 REFLECTION: Write down: 3 facts you have learned, 2 insights or understandings you have gained, and 1 question that you still have or would like to learn more about.Then comment on the comments of other students.

Fig. 24: Celebration of ANZACs after World War 1

 

For the Teacher

Teaching Tip

Provide the categories to students to prompt connections between the Memory Box objects and their research focus.

 Possible Focus Areas

Women at War

  • What was life like for women left at home?
  • What roles did Australian women play in the war effort in Australia?
  • How did their roles change?
  • Describe the experience of nurses at war.

Soldiers at War

  • What was life like in the trenches?
  • Was the Australian soldier ready for war (training, rations, uniform, equipment)?
  • What was it like for soldiers at Gallipoli?
  • Reasearch a soldiers experience using official documents.
  • What weapons did they use? Did new developments in technology actually extend the war?

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander experience

  • What was life like for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders at war?
  • What were the differences?
  • How were they treated?
  • How were they treated when they return?

Conscription

  • Why would Australia need conscription?
  • What were the arguments for and against conscription?
  • What groups of people were for and against conscription?

The home front

  • What was life like for children at home?
  • What was life like for women at home?
  • What was life like for civilians close to the Western Front?
  • How did Australia react to being at war?
  • What types of propaganda was used to persuade men to enlist?
  • How were the German's treated in Australia when the war broke out?

The legacy of World War One

  • Why should we commemorate World War One?
  • What is the ANZAC spirit?
  • Lessons learnt from World War One
  • Life after war.
  • What was the impact of World War One?

 

25. Acknowledgements

The original version of this learning module was written by Jennifer Nott, Laura Hicks and Prue Gill.

Title: (Source); Fig. 1: (Source); Fig. 2: (Source); Fig. 3: Map Cartoon (Source); Fig. 4: Reading Map (Source); Fig. 5: (Source); Fig. 6: (Source); Fig. 7: (Source); Fig. 8: (Source); Fig. 9: (Source); Fig. 10: (Source); Fig. 11: Recruitment poster (Source); Fig. 12: Egypt (Source);  Fig. 13: (Source); Fig. 15: (Source); Fig. 16: The Blood Vote (Source); Fig. 17: The Death Ballot (Source);  Fig. 22: Simpson (Source); Fig. 23: (Source).