In authentic assessments, students apply concepts to real-life situations by completing meaningful task-based assessments. This type of assessment covers a wide range of skills and effectively measures higher levels of learning than traditional assessment. Authentic assessment helps students to develop skills, challenge them to practice creative thinking and problem-solving, and enable multiple means of demonstrating their knowledge. (University of Florida, n.d.) This module is designed for K-12 teachers and educators. Through this module, participants will be learning about the basics of authentic assessment, why it should be used in the classroom, and developing a form of authentic assessment for their own classroom.
authentic assessment, creating assessment
Since the early 1990s, teachers, educators, theorists and researchers have advocated authentic assessment as a more effective approach towards student evaluation. (Frey, Schmitt, & Allen, 2012). In authentic assessments, students apply concepts to real-life situations by completing meaningful task-based assessments. This type of assessment covers a wide range of skills and effectively measures higher levels of learning than traditional assessment. Authentic assessment helps students to develop skills, challenge them to practice creative thinking and problem-solving, and enable multiple means of demonstrating their knowledge. (University of Florida, n.d.)
This module is designed for K-12 teachers and educators. Through this module, participants will be learning about the basics of authentic assessment, why it should be used in the classroom, and developing a form of authentic assessment for their own classroom. The module consists of 6 sessions; each session is intended to be 45 minutes to 1 hour long. At the end of each session, there will be a reflective question for participants to reflect upon their thoughts and what they have learned. At the end of the module, they will receive an assignment to apply what they have learned to create an entirely new assessment opportunity for students.
I have taught this course face-to-face before and decided to redesign it as an online learning module, which can be delivered in either synchronous or asynchronous mode. According to the National Research Council (2007), online professional development can change teachers’ practice and has other potential benefits such as:
Acknowledgement
This learning module references and uses some activities designed by the following individuals and organizations:
Authentic Assessment Toolbox (created by John Mueller)
Teaching and Learning in Higher Education
The Knowledge Network for Innovations in Learning and Teaching (KNILT)
After completing this course, the participant will be able to:
1. Understand what authentic assessment is and its benefits in the classroom.
2. Understand the various types of authentic assessment that can be implemented in the classroom.
3. Understand the step-by-step process of creating an authentic assessment opportunity.
4. Evaluate their own student assessment and design a new assessment opportunity incorporating the basics of authentic assessment.
This learning module is aligned with the following categories of The Cambridge Teacher Standards, a benchmark for teachers to evaluate their own practice and guide their continuing professional development:
5.1. plan for progression in learning by designing effective learning sequences within lessons and across series of lessons.
5.2. set explicit, challenging and achievable learning goals for all students.
5.7. make effective use of formative and summative assessment to support student learning and monitor levels of achievement and attainment.
5.8. use the outcomes of assessment to identify students’ learning needs, set targets for improvement, and plan for future teaching and learning interventions.
5.9. provide students, colleagues and parents with timely, accurate and constructive feedback on students’ progress in learning, attainment and areas for development.
The goal of this Pre-Assessment aims to help you examine your current knowledge of concepts and principles related to assessment.
This course is best suited for educators who have:
Instructor may use the information from these surveys to understand participants' backgrounds and arrange pairs of learning partners in peer feedback activity. Usually, participants with a similar interest/ background will be paired. However, there will also be a few other exceptions to ensure that you have the opportunity to learn from new and critical perspectives.
By the end of this session, you will:
1. What is Authentic Assessment
The term “authentic assessment” commonly refers to assessments that measure not only what students have learned from the content of the course, but also their ability to apply that knowledge in certain real-life situation. (University of Florida, n.d.)
Watch the video below to see how Educators at New York School of The Future have enjoyed great success at teaching and assessing their students with authentic assessment.
Video: Authentic" Assessment at School of the Future (Edutopia, 2012)
Bergen (as cited in Frey, Schmitt, & Allen, 1993) identifies three qualities of authentic assessment:
(1) The context of the assessment | (2) The role of the student | (3) The scoring |
|
|
|
2. The differences between Traditional and Authentic Assessment
Video: The Differences Between Traditional and Authentic Assessment (Steven Thompson, 2016)
The table below from Wiggins (1998) compares traditional assessments (tests and exams) to authentic assessments (tasks).
REFLECTION
Comment: How does this relate to your classroom? Would you be able to incorporate this type of assessment? What are key ideas that you can keep and use in your classroom? How are the students personally benefiting from this type of assessment?
Make an update: "Authentic assessment does not compete with traditional assessments like tests. Rather, they complement each other." (John Mueller). Make an update to share your thought on this statement.
Relevant Readings for Instructor
By the end of this session, you will:
1. Activity: Examples of Authentic Assessment
Below are a couple of examples of authentic assessments in different subjects. Fill in the table with some other examples that you know.
Source: Indiana University Bloomington's Center for Innovative Teaching and Learning
Nursing | Provide a case study of a patient and ask students to assess and create a plan of care |
Computer Science | Troubleshoot a problemmatic piece of code; Develop a website/app to solve a particular problem and/or meet a set of criteria |
Psychology | Examine/critique a case study from multiple theoretical positions |
Public Affairs or Service Learning Course | Consider how a community agency might be impacted by a particular challenge (budget cuts, infrastructure outage, public health crisis, etc.) |
Biology/Chemistry | Draw a diagram of how a process works, indicating what happens if X occurs |
History | Engage in a role play of a particular event in history; Describe what might have happened if one element of a historical event had changed. |
Your Example 1 | |
Your Example 2 | |
Your Example 3 |
2. 4 steps of creating authentic assessments
John Muller created the following graphic to summarize the process and highlight important questions to ask in each step:
REFLECTION
Comment: What new information did you gain regarding the steps to creating authentic assessment?
Update: Were you already creating assignments in this way? If not, what ways could you improve upon how you are currently creating student assessment?
Instructors may use the description below to clarify the process with students when teaching this class in synchronous mode.
(Source: The Knowledge Network for Innovations in Learning and Teaching)
STEP 1 - Standards
An assignment should always be formed with standards and objectives in mind (backwards design). In order to create a task for students to complete, you must first ask yourself, "what should my students know following this lesson and assignment". This will give you a starting point for creating varoius ideas for assessment. You must first start by having the end result of the assignment in mind. Once you have decided what you want your students to get out of their task, you can move on to step 2.
STEP 2 - Authentic Tasks
In this step, a teacher will decide how they want students to portray their knowledge of the subject matter using a real-world activity or scenario. A task should be chosen for students to complete that meets the authentic assessment criteria. It should be a meaningful task that students feel they can relate to and can apply in their lives.
STEP 3 - Criteria/Measures
In step 3, you will decide what the student performing the assignment or task or will look like. What would you like the end product to be? You have already chosen how you want the student to portray their knowledge through an authentic task, and you must now determine what that will look like and what criteria will prove student understanding. In other words, how will you know that the student has performed well or not? Knowing what criteria you are looking for in an authentic assignment will assist you in the next step - creating a rubric.
STEP 4 - Rubric
After you have decided what task you would like students to complete, and what criteria you will use to decide whether or not they have meet the standards, you will create a rubric for evaluation of students. A rubric is a way for you to evaluate what level of performance the students are currently performing at. Rubrics will be discussed further in this unit.
By the end of this session, you will be able to:
1. What are educational standards
Educational standards are the learning goals for what students should know and be able to do in each grade. Education standards, like CommonCore are not curriculums. Local communities and educators choose their own curriculum, which is a detailed plan for everyday teaching. In other words, the Common Core is what students need to know and be able to do, and the curriculum is how students will learn it. (Common Core State Standards Initiatives, n.d)
John Mueller distinguish standards from other statements of student performance primarily along two dimensions: 1) breadth of coverage and 2) feasibility of measurement and observation.
2. Types of standards
- Content standards: Statements that explain what students need to know or can do within content in a particular discipline or at the intersection of two or more disciplines. For example: Students will classify objects along two dimensions.
- Process standards: Statements that describe the skills that a student needs to develop to enhance the learning process. Process standards are not specific to a particular discipline, but are general skills that can be applied to all disciplines.. For example: Find and evaluate relevant information.
- Value standards: statements that describe attitudes teachers would like students to develop towards learning. For example: Students will value diversity of opinions or perspectives.
Activity: Is it a Content, Process or Value standard?
Look at the following statement in the table below and identify whether it is a Content, a Process or a Value standard:
Standard | Content, Process or Value? |
Students will be able to add two-digit numbers. | |
Students will set realistic goals for their performance. |
|
Describe effects of physical activity on the body. |
|
Take responsible risks | |
Present employment-related information in the target language | |
Persist on challenging tasks. |
|
Seriously consider the ideas of others. |
|
Students will write a coherent essay |
3. Aligning standards, objectives and assessments
Video: Aligning Standards, Objectives and Assessments (New Pathways to Teaching in New Jersey, 2020)
RELEVANT READINGS
Standards examples (Authentic Assessment Toolbox)
REFLECTION
Comment: What are some pros and cons of standards on education and training?
Update: Make an update to share your own tips/ best practices for writing a good standard?
Possible answers for Activity: Activity: Is it a Content, Process or Value standard?
Standard | Content, Process or Value? |
Students will be able to add two-digit numbers. | Content |
Students will set realistic goals for their performance. | Process |
Describe effects of physical activity on the body. | Content |
Take responsible risks | Value |
Present employment-related information in the target language | Content |
Persist on challenging tasks. | Value |
Seriously consider the ideas of others. | Value |
Students will write a coherent essay | Process, Content |
The same standard could be either a content or a process standard. For example, the standard students will write a coherent essay would be a process standard in a history course because it does not describe the content within the history discipline. Instead, it describes a useful skill that historians should have along with those working in other disciplines. However, if the same standard were part of an English composition course, it could be labeled as a content standard because students would be learning the content of that discipline. Yes, writing skills are useful in any discipline, but it is being taught as content for the course in the composition course.
Relevant materials for instructors:
Authentic Assessment Toolbox - Step 1: Identify the Standards
By the end of this session, you will be able to:
1. What is authentic task
An authentic task is an assignment in which learners apply objective-driven knowledge and skills to real-world challenges. We are less interested in how much knowledge students can acquire than how well they can use it.
Types of authentic tasks:
- Constructed-response items: Students construct an answer from old and new knowledge in response to a prompt.
- Performances: In response to an assignment, students construct a performance that reveals their understanding of specific concepts and skills and/or their ability to apply, analyze, synthesize or evaluate those concepts and skills.
- Products: In response to an assignment, students construct a performance that reveals their understanding of specific concepts and skills and/or their ability to apply, analyze, synthesize or evaluate those concepts and skills.
2. Examples of authentic tasks
Video: Classroom Examples of Authentic Assessment (Huynh, N.B., 2020)
Video: Building Formative Assessment into Game-Based Learning (Edutopia, 2014)
The following table (Teaching and Learning in Higher Education, n.d.) summarize general categories/types of authentic tasks:
Type of task | Example |
Memo, Letters to the editors, Email This type of project encourages students to use their imaginations but also to research and collate an explicit and tangible body of knowledge in their discipline while at the same time developing critical and professional written and communication skills. |
Students in Finance might be asked to write a client memo; students in Recreation and Leisure Studies might be asked to write a letter to the editor of a local newspaper about a community concern; and students in Visual Culture might be asked to write an e-mail to an imagined manager about a magazine cover they are currently designing. |
Presentation (including Poster Presentation) The idea of having students take their work and make it public within the context of the classroom not only encourages students to invest more time and thought into their work but also immediately connects to the development of professional skills and of presentation skills for a variety of audiences |
Students in Chemistry might present on how to balance a simple combustion reaction; students in Rhetoric might present a major research paper; and students in Mechanical Engineering might present a unit manufacturing process of ceramic casting. |
Proposals, Policy briefs and Reports A policy brief and/or report asks students to address in a professional manner – for which the intended audience is other professionals interested in the problem, investigation, research, etc. – a research question, course of action, decision, theory, etc. that is of interest and importance. |
Students in Psychology might write a proposal for an experimental study; students in Applied Mathematics write a policy report of ethical navigation of stock option prices and students in Biology might write a report on their own dietary analysis. |
Case studies or Simulation games Case studies present a fictional scenario that leads up to one (or more) dilemma that requires problem solving or decision-making. When in-class time, however, can be given over for students to act out these case studies, with different students playing different assigned roles from the fictional scenarios, the case study then becomes a simulation game |
Students in Pharmacy might enact a simulation game of a case study on drug information and patient safety; students in Peace and Conflict Studies might take on a simulation game of a case study involving international development; and students in Nanotechnology might present a simulation game of a case study concerning the testing of environmental pollutants. |
Fishbowls In a fishbowl assignment, small numbers of students are picked to sit the “hot seats” in the centre of class where they respond to questions, concerns, ideas, etc. about subject matter that will have been passed out prior to the fishbowl activity date. This assessment strategy is a variation of the flipped-classroom teaching method, and it develops in students professional skillsets for active listening and critical inquiry as well as professional communication, presentation, and group discussion skills. Video: Fishbowl Problem Solving Circle (Childhood Development Initiative, 2015) |
Students in Sexuality, Marriage, and Family Studies might prepare for and discuss issues of surrogate motherhood; students in Earth and Space Science might prepare for and discuss methods of instrumentation and observation of different wavelengths; and students in Acrylic Painting prepare for and discuss innovative application techniques and mark-making. |
REFLECTION
Comment: How does this relate to your classroom? Would you be able to incorporate this type of assessment? What are key ideas that you can keep and use in my classroom? How are the students personally benefiting from this type of assignment?
Update: Think about your favorite assignment from when you were a student and make an update about it. What was it about that particular assignment that made it so engaging and memorable for you? How did it support your learning in that specific project? How did it help your learning in the course as a whole? What kinds of transferable skills did you learn through it?
Relevant Materials for Instructor:
Many educators ask how they can gage a student's learning in an online course. They often wonder what could possibly replace the traditional lectures that have worked so well in a face-to-face classroom setting.
Read this detailed Examples of Authentic Assessments in an online or hybrid course.(Miami University, n.d)
By the end of this session, you will be able to:
Understand how to make assessment criteria clear to students.
1. Why is clear assessment criteria important?
Activity: Say “Yes” (…or “No”) to the Dress. (This activity was designed by Teaching and Learning in Higher Education)
Instructions: In this activity you are asked to assume the role of an assessor who is asked to evaluate the dress our model is wearing. Follow the following steps to review the criteria for rating the dress.
Step 1: Consider the dress our model is wearing and rate it. |
Image: “Eye and Flower Dress.” By DeusXFlorida |
Step 2: Consider the dress our model is wearing, and rate it in terms of its suitability and colour. | |
Step 3: Consider the dress our model is wearing, and rate it in terms of:
Rate each criteria on a scale from 1 to 4, where 1 is low and 4 is high. |
This activity helps you experience how different levels of clarity in an assignment can prepare learners for completing a task. The degree of clarity and precision with which we design our questions and problems in an assignment– i.e. with no criteria, vague criteria, or clear criteria – directly impacts how much we have set up our students for success. The clarity of assignment criteria not only helps to determine the ease and motivation to perform tasks, but also the quality of results, depending on how they interpret the expectations.
Video: Developing Success Criteria ((TCDSB 21C, 2015)
2. Learning Goals vs. Criteria
Learning Goals | Success Criteria |
answer the question "Where am I going" | answer the question "How am I going?" |
refer to understanding, knowledge, skills, or application. |
a concrete learning performance: something students will say, do, make, or write to indicate they are moving toward the Learning Goal. |
often begin with verbs like know, develop, become fluent, apply, understand, use, or extend |
Success Criteria often begin with verbs like explain, describe, model, show, write, justify, or create. |
Some examples of Learning Goals and Success Criteria (Oregon Department of Education, n.d.)
3. Characteristic of a good criterion:
Make sure each criterion is unique. Although the criteria for a single task will understandably be related to one another, there should not be too much overlap between them.
By giving students a voice in the assessment process, they can learn more effectively and be motivated when actively involved in their learning.
Video: Co-creating Success Criteria (Maryland Formative Assessment, 2016)
RELEVANT READING:
Step 3: Identify the Criteria for the Task (John Mueller, n.d)
REFLECTION:
Comment: How does this relate to your classroom? What are key ideas that you can keep and use in my classroom? How are the students personally benefiting from this practice?
Update: Consider the benefits and challenges of involving students in the assessment process. Make an update to share your thoughts on this.
Relevant materials for Instructor:
Bloom Taxonomy Action Verbs (Fresno State, n.d)
Criteria and Descriptors (Government of Ontario's Curriculum and Resources, n.d)
By the end of this session, you will be able to:
1. Types of rubrics
Rubrics are tools designed for the following purposes:
The following 3-minute video will introduce you to two types of rubrics, holistic and analytical.
Video: Types of Rubrics ((National Park College Online, 2015)
2. Characteristics of an effective rubric
The rubric consists of the following elements (Teaching and Learning in Higher Education, n.d.):
Criteria - characteristics of what the performance should look like. Criteria was step 3 of the 4-step process of developing authentic assessment.
Levels of Performance: different performance levels are written for each selected criterion. A simple performance level (Government of Ontario's Curriculum and Resources, n.d.) can be displayed as follows
Video: Rubric for Assessment (Teacher Training - World Learning, 2018)
3. Creating a rubric
Video: 7 Steps for Creating Rubric (Katie Datko, 2017).
Questions to consider when creating rubric:
Some examples of rubrics:
Group projects
Written work
Critical Thinking
Online discussion boards
RELEVANT READING:
Step 4: Create the Rubric (John Mueller, n.d)
REFLECTION:
Comment: Are you currently creating rubrics to assess your student's performance? What did you get out of creating or recreating a rubric for a current student assignment?
Update: As far back as assessments have been used in education, there have been students who stated that the assessment was ‘unfair’. What makes an assessment ‘fair’ or ‘unfair’? Make an update to share your thoughts on this.
Relevant materials for Instructor
RubiStar - a free tool to help teachers create quality rubrics.
Fair Assessment Practices: Giving Students Equitable Opportunties to Demonstrate Learning (Suskie, 2000)
(Acknowledgement: This activity was designed by The Knowledge Network for Innovations in Learning and Teaching)
Now that you've learned all the basics of authentic assessment, it's time to create your own real classroom learning opportunities. Use what you have learned to revise an assignment you are currently using for your students or create entirely new assessment opportunities for your students. In any case, your students will benefit from the fact that you are creating tasks that are directly related to real-life experience.
Please keep the following things in mind while creating your own assessment:
You will also be responsible for reviewing and providing feedback on at least 3 assessments generated by your colleagues, using the following rubric:
Rubric for peer review task
CRITERIA |
LEVEL 1 Lack essential features of authentic assessment |
LEVEL 2 Needs further development |
LEVEL 3 Incorporate best authentic assessment practices |
1.Standards | Outcome statements do not identify what students can do to demonstrate learning. There is no clear relationship between the outcomes and the task | Most of the outcomes indicate how students can demonstrate their learning | Outcomes describe clearly how students can demonstrate their learning. |
2. Authentic task
|
. Students have no or little opportunity to apply knowledge and skills to real world challenges | Students appear to be given reasonable opportunities to develop the outcomes in the required task and to apply knowledge and skills to real world challenges. | The task is designed to provide opportunities for students to apply knowledge and skills to real world challenges, and is explicitly and intentionally aligned with each outcome. |
3. Success criteria | Criteria being assessed are unclear, have significant overlap, or are not derived from appropriate standards for product/ task and subject area | Criteria being assessed can be identified, but not all are clearly differentiated or derived from appropriate standards for product/task and subject area | All criteria are clear, distinct, and derived from appropriate standards for product/ task and subject area |
4. Rubric | Little/no distinction between levels | Some distinction between levels is evident, but remain unclear | Each level is distinct and progresses in a clear and logical order |
You may use the data from the pre-assessment to match participants in this peer-review assignment . Below are common characteristics to consider when composing groups: (1) Prior knowledge, previous experiences, and skills. (2) Motivation/ Kind of challenges they want to solve. (3) Diversity of perspectives.
Some other questions you might want to explore with your learners:
We have three major metrics for evaluation:
(1) Demonstrated Knowledge
Completion of Final Assignment
Quality of Final Assignment. (Your self-review score and the score submitted by your peers for your assignment)
Completion of three (03) peer reviews
(2) Focus, or the amount of effort you have put into the course
Six (06) or more comments on admin updates
Six (06) updates you created
200 words per individual updates you created
Completion of Pre-assessment
(3) Help, or the amount of collaboration based on your contribution to the community and peer interaction
Fifteen (15) comments on your peer updates.
We have three major metrics for evaluation:
(1) Demonstrated Knowledge
(2) Focus (or the amount of effort learners have put into the course)
(3) Help (the amount of collaboration based on learners' contribution to the community and peer interaction)
You may adjust the details of each category to suit your own requirements for learners.
*Fresno State. (n.d.). Bloom's Taxonomy Action Verbs. Retrieved from http://www.fresnostate.edu/academics/oie/documents/assesments/Blooms%20Level.pdf
*Common Core State Standards Initiative. ( n.d). What are educational standards. http://www.corestandards.org/faq/what-are-educational-standards/
*Frey, B. B., Schmitt, V. L., & Allen, J. P. (2012). Defining Authentic Classroom Assessment. Practical Assessment, Research and Evaluation, 17(2), 1-18. Retrieved 2 19, 2022, from http://pareonline.net/pdf/v17n2.pdf
*Government of Ontario's Curriculum and Resources. (n.d) Criteria and Descriptors. Criteria and Descriptors.
*Oregon Department of Education (n.d). Criteria Success and Goals Learning for Tips Writing. https://www.oregon.gov/ode/educator-resources/assessment/Documents/writing_tips_learning_goals_success_criteria.pdf
*Teaching and Learning in Higher Education. (n.d.). Designing Authentic Assessment. https://www.queensu.ca/teachingandlearning/modules/assessments/20_s2_12_designing_authentic_assessments.html
*University of Florida (n.d). Building Authentic Assessments. https://citt.ufl.edu/resources/assessing-student-learning/building-authentic-assessments/
*University of Wisconsin-Madison (n.d). Authentic Assessment. https://courses.dcs.wisc.edu/design-teaching/PlanDesign_Fall2016/2-Online-Course-Design/3_Learning-Assessments/9_assessment_summative-authentic.html
*Wiggins, G. (n.d). What Are The Characteristics Of Authentic Assessment?. TeachThought University. https://www.teachthought.com/pedagogy/authentic-assessment/
MEDIA
Edutopia (2012, June 11). “Authentic" Assessment at School of the Future. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9l5m66Y607U
Teachings in Education (2017, January 17). Authentic Assessment: Examples & Overview. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rQPCk27tM4U
New Pathways to Teaching in New Jersey (December 28, 2020). Aligning Standards, Objectives and Assessments. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vXsn_sxpAmU
Huynh Nguyen Bao (2020, 8 November). Classroom Examples of Authentic Assessment. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YknmUvh34ro 8 Nov 2020
Maryland Formative Assessment. (January 14, 2016). Co-creating success criteria. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MyfjODZCkF4
TCDSB 21C (February 18, 2015). Developing Success Criteria. [Video]. YouTube.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eJ-RvrsZUSE
National Park College Online. (2015, August 15). Types of Rubrics. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ekA93i5X0sg
Katie Datko (2017, April 11). 7 Steps for Creating Rubrics. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vfRP9HGVHGo