Produced with Scholar
Icon for Character Education

Character Education

A Learning Module for the Emerging Servant Leaders Program

Learning Module

Abstract

This learning module is the fourth and final component in a series comprising the Emerging Servant Leaders Program (ESLP), an initiative to engage youth who wish to grow as leaders by serving a cause larger than self. The ESLP is built on the notion that self-government in a free, representative republic doesn’t happen spontaneously but requires adults’ proactive involvement to convey wisdom to future generations. Its goal is to develop a cadre of kind, thoughtful, and engaged young citizens for our region, state, and nation. Designed for high school students, the ESLP is composed of six online/classroom hybrid learning modules plus an in-person capstone experience. This particular module offers lessons on responsibility, gratitude, and attitude.

Keywords

Character Education, Moral Education, Citizenship Education, Personal Responsibility

Overview

The Emerging Servant Leaders Program (ESLP) is a new program for Ohio high school students that is being designed for The Grindstone Institute, also known as Grindstone, a leadership development organization I established in 2019. Grindstone honors my hometown of Berea, Ohio, which was known in the 1800s as the “Grindstone Capital of the World” (Ohio History Central, n.d.). In much the same way that grindstones were used to sharpen tools, Grindstone’s programs aim to sharpen people by helping them hone the leadership skills our community, nation, and world need (The Grindstone Institute, 2020). Its curriculum leverages my two decades of professional experience in state and federal government, the U.S. Navy, and nonprofit leadership organizations, which I now seek to share with future leaders as I continue my journey of mentoring and lifelong learning.

The ESLP aligns directly with the personal leadership project I am designing as a 2020-2021 Presidential Leadership Scholar (Presidential Leadership Scholars, 2020) and a Doctor of Education candidate at the University of Illinois. Over the past twelve months in previous Learning Design and Leadership core courses, I have designed most of the curriculum for the ESLP in three learning modules (Dovilla, 2019a; Dovilla, 2019b; Dovilla, 2020), a process which will be completed with this fourth and final contribution to the initiative. This particular learning module offers lessons on responsibility, gratitude, and attitude, three important traits in character education that happen to complement the educational psychology concepts being explored in this course. Other modules have included self-awareness, civility, citizenship, and capstone featuring online elements followed by an experiential learning component – a daytrip to the state capital in Columbus that includes the opportunity for intergenerational interaction with military veterans.

Overall, the ESLP is built on extensive scholarly literature and anecdotal evidence that young people lack the robust civic knowledge needed for democratic self-governance (National Center for Education Statistics, 2018) and exhibit troubling levels of anxiety and depression (Horowitz & Graf, 2019). The ESLP seeks to address both issues by: (1) improving awareness of historical context and understanding of current policy matters through civil, civic dialogue; and (2) shifting focus away from the self by encouraging participants to consider how they can help and serve others in their communities.

Intended Learning Outcomes

Target Learners

The initial design of the Emerging Servant Leaders Program (ESLP) is being prepared for high school students; however, it is envisioned to be adaptable for younger or older students in grades K-8 or college. As noted in the capstone module (Dovilla, 2020), the ESLP seeks to fill a gap in citizenship preparation that has been caused, in part, by increased emphases on (1) high-stakes testing outcomes and (2) promotion to college primarily for job preparation. In addition, and to the point of this course on educational psychology, the program is built on the notion that citizenship education is based to some extent on behavioral skills honed through character education (Althof & Berkowitz, 2006; Hoge, 2002) and that schools may benefit from incorporating such extracurricular programming. In that regard, the ESLP is not intended to supplant existing high school curriculum but to come alongside districts, schools, and educators that may be looking for partnership opportunities to assist in preparing young citizens to be actively engaged adults in their communities and society.

Rationale for Learning Outcomes (Learner)

The ESLP is designed to improve learners’ self-awareness, civility, citizenship, responsibility, gratitude, and attitude – all important traits in character and citizenship education. This learning module, featuring content on the last three of those characteristics, builds on what has been learned in earlier modules. It seeks to address the root causes of several challenges that manifest in today’s culture, including the notion that being a celebrity or social media “influencer” is more important than being accountable to oneself and others, grateful for what one has, or resilient and optimistic enough to overcome life's routine obstacles. It is hoped that offering character education in these areas will provide a broader perspective on how to be a mature, others-focused individual who seeks to contribute to rather than take from society.

Rationale for Learning Outcomes (Teacher)

The ESLP is being developed as a supplemental curriculum to what is now typically offered in American high schools. As federal and state testing standards have shifted increasingly to measuring mathematics, English language arts, and the sciences, character and citizenship education has fallen by the wayside for lack of resources. Yet preparing young people to assume their roles and responsibilities as participants and leaders in American society has long been considered a key purpose of public education in the United States. Teachers who engage in this program can be confident they are making a significant additional contribution to the country’s future by improving young people’s understanding of themselves and how they can pursue meaningful lives in the service of others.

Anticipated Duration

The Emerging Servant Leaders Program includes seven online modules, three of which are developed in this work. Each individual online module is designed as a preparatory element that should be supplemented with a synchronous session offered either online or onsite. Following the seventh online module, students will participate in a one-day in-person capstone, an intergenerational service learning experience that brings together students and military veterans. The application of ESLP as an extracurricular program is flexible in that it may be executed during summer vacation with weekly sessions or during the academic year with monthly sessions on weekends.

Responsibility: Accountability

For the Learner

Contemporary society has a tendency to focus disproportionately on individual rights while neglecting the other side of that equation: responsibility. Although certain responsibilities are legally required, such as serving on a jury when called, others are voluntary, yet important, in maintaining the freedom, liberty, and equality of one another in our free society, like participating in the democratic process by voting (U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, n.d.). It is important that we have awareness of both types of responsibilities.

Examples of a citizen’s rights and responsibilities (U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, n.d.).

One definition of responsibility is to be accountable or answerable (Bennett, 1993). A good citizen must be aware that his or her actions, even if we think they affect only oneself, impact others. The Class of 2020 graduate featured in the following video explains the ways in which she carried forward the character trait of responsibility she learned in elementary school to provide leadership as a class officer during all four years in high school.

Media embedded July 18, 2020

Characterdotorg. (2020, 29 June). Kyla. [Video]. YouTube.

Comment: Based on the observations Kyla shared in the video, make a comment about the ways in which she demonstrated personal responsibility throughout her years in school. What stood out to you in the stories she offered about her experiences?

Update: Now, give some thought to your own conception of accountability. Draw from your personal experience and describe a time when you lived up to – or fell short of – your responsibility to do right by yourself and others. Or, discuss an example from the news where a leader did the right thing by accepting – rather than avoiding – blame when he or she did something wrong. Also, think about what difference it makes when an individual chooses to take complete ownership for his or her actions.

For the Teacher

Purpose:

At its root, any exploration of responsibility or accountability is about morality, which is the basis of law in any civil society. Here in the United States, we find evidence of this premise in the very seat of the federal government. Encircling the gallery of the U.S. House of Representatives are 23 marble portraits of lawgivers drawn from ancient and modern history, individuals whose principles helped fashion the American form of self-government nearly two-and-a-half centuries ago.

Historical lawgivers offer a basis for responsibility rooted in morality (Architect of the Capitol. (n.d.).

Resources & Teaching Suggestions:

Our nation’s founding principles of freedom, liberty, and equality, which clearly developed unevenly for different segments of the population during American history, represent an ongoing effort to realize the “more perfect union” envisioned in the U.S. Constitution. This discussion of responsibility provides an opportune time to discuss some of the historical figures who have challenged the American people to live up to the principles we say we believe in (Bennett, 1993; Self, n.d.):

  • Thomas Jefferson – Declaration of Independence – the moral obligation to preserve, protect, and defend our God-given rights for other people
  • Frederick Douglas – The Conscience of the Nation Must Be Roused – the need to hold America accountable for its original sin of slavery, a violation of the basic moral obligation toward our fellow men and women
  • Martin Luther King, Jr. – Letter from Birmingham City Jail – the clear articulation of justifiable grounds for civil disobedience in the fight for equality

An excellent one-stop resource may be found at Learning to Give, an organization that provides teaching resources to K-12 teachers. Its page on civic responsibility offers many relevant topics for discussion with students.

https://www.learningtogive.org/resources/civic-responsibility

 

Responsibility: Maturity

For the Learner

Another way to take responsibility is to exhibit maturity, that is, to be a person who owns his or her actions, owns up to them, and answers for them (Bennett, 1993). But modern society has a strange way of looking at these concepts. Perhaps one of the most telling ways in which this manifests itself is the development of the term “adulting,” an ironic attempt to describe the mundane sorts of things adults do (Sasse, 2017). In reflecting on adulting, Dr. Ben Sasse, a former university president who now represents Nebraska in the U.S. Senate, observes, “Ours is now an odd nation of both delayed grown-ups and adult-children who create words to mock the idea that we could ever become responsible, civic-minded leaders” (Sasse, 2017, pp. 1-2).

Maturity also has an important emotional element that many people lack due to their upbringing, an aptitude that requires training like any other skill (The School of Life, 2019). When we take responsibility for our emotions and our reactions to circumstances or people that challenge or even hurt us, we demonstrate the sort of maturity needed to navigate adulthood. This is an essential skill if we are to be actively engaged citizens who are others-focused enough to make a meaningful contribution to those around us.

The following video suggests that for as many as half of us, if we haven’t had it modeled properly during childhood, acquiring emotional maturity is like learning a foreign language (The School of Life, 2019):

Media embedded July 19, 2020

The School of Life. (2019, 13 November). How to test your emotional maturity. [Video]. YouTube.

Comment: After watching the video, please make a comment on your thoughts about the three cardinal virtues of emotional maturity – communication, trust, and vulnerability. Offer your perspective on whether you think learning this skill is easier or harder than learning a foreign language. What challenges are you experiencing in developing maturity in accepting responsibility for your actions and emotions?

Update: Share an example of a situation in which you have reacted with one of the three signs of emotionally immature behavior (sulking, anger, or coldness) indicating someone who has not developed responsibility for his or her emotions. Reflecting on that memory, discuss what you might have done differently to reflect one of the virtuous responses described in the video.

For the Teacher

Purpose:

This is admittedly a challenging module to teach, particularly in attempting to reach the many young (and not-so-young) people in modern society who have not had good examples of emotionally intelligent adults to follow. But that’s why it is so important. As Sen. Sasse suggests, the United States was designed to have citizens, not subjects, and that construct assumes a developed degree of maturity among its adults – people who take responsibility for their actions, emotions, and interactions with others (Sasse, 2017).

Having passed the halfway point in the ESLP, you should now be preparing your students for the capstone project, a facilitated model legislative session where each participant will present and debate with peers a public policy issue he or she has selected and prepared for consideration. Among other skills, this exercise will require emotional intelligence, the basics of which you might wish to discuss during this module’s synchronous session.

Resources & Teaching Suggestions:

Daniel Goleman is one of the foremost academic leaders on emotional intelligence. In this video, he offers a good synopsis of why we should be teaching emotional intelligence in schools and describes some of its basic components:

Media embedded July 19, 2020

Big Think. (2012, 23 April). Daniel Goleman introduces emotional intelligence. [Video]. YouTube.

Gratitude: Thankfulness

For the Learner

Gratitude creates in us a feeling of obligation and the sense that it’s our responsibility to pay forward the gifts we’ve been given. It stands in direct contrast to the modern realities we so often feel, including comparing ourselves to others, experiencing fear of missing out (“FOMO”), or even expressing a sense of entitlement that we deserve to have something.

The notion that we ought to be thankful for what we have and not covet others’ belongings has its moral roots in the Ten Commandments, and it also has practical applications. Theodore Roosevelt, our 26th president, is credited, among others, with observing that “comparison is the thief of joy.” When we consider that this sentiment came from a man whose mother and first wife died within hours of one another on the same day when Roosevelt was only 25 years old but who went on to receive the Medal of Honor and become the youngest man to serve as president of the United States, it offers some important perspective on the value of working hard and being thankful for what we have.

Upon assuming the presidency in 1901 after the assassination of President William McKinley, Roosevelt continued the tradition begun by President Lincoln in 1863 of celebrating Thanksgiving. Here are some of the words he used in his 1903 proclamation:

Media embedded July 19, 2020

Washington Post. (2018, 21 November). A Thanksgiving message from Teddy Roosevelt — and Post opinions. [Video]. YouTube.

Comment: What are your thoughts on some of the sentiments shared by President Roosevelt in his Thanksgiving proclamation of 1903? For example, he quotes from Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address (“of the people, by the people, for the people”) as an example of liberty to the world, he expresses gratitude to God for the blessings bestowed on Americans, and he makes a distinction between the powers of good and evil in the world. Many of these notions are no longer prevalent in popular culture. What impact do you believe our lack of gratitude as a function of morality is having on our society today?

Update: Please take some time to reflect on the privileges we enjoy as Americans and make your own update to share your thoughts with your peers. Or, think of a time when you demonstrated a sense of entitlement rather than thankfulness for something you received or thought you should have received.

For the Teacher

Purpose:

It seems as if every generation complains that younger generations don’t have as much of any number of virtues as the ones that preceded it. Most of the time, this can be chalked up to so much grousing, as not all that much really changes in the way people treat one another. As long as people have walked the earth, they have exhibited jealousy, covetousness, and entitlement. This only underscores the importance of teaching gratitude, without which young people enter the adult world and quickly become frustrated they haven’t instantaneously realized all of their dreams or had all of their desires fulfilled.

Resources & Teaching Suggestions:

Among other resources being developed for this module, the author of the following piece opines that entitlement is, in fact, a problem among today's youth and that it can be addressed by teaching gratitude:

https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-to-raise-more-grateful-children-1519398748

Gratitude: Kindness

For the Learner

Another aspect of gratitude is encapsulated in the idea that we ought to offer or return kindness or compassion to others. From Aesop’s fable of the lion and the mouse, to the parable of the Good Samaritan, to the acts of Clara Barton, the Civil War’s “Angel of the Battlefield” and founder of the American Red Cross, kindness is a timeless virtue (Bennett, 1993).

Watch the following video to learn about some of the practical implications of kindness:

Media embedded July 19, 2020

randomactsofkindness. (2017, 13 November). The science of kindness. [Video]. YouTube.

Comment: What are your thoughts on the scientific and other benefits of kindness described in the video?

Update: Share a “random act of kindness” with the class that you believe would be a good way to show another person or our community the value of compassion toward others.

For the Teacher

Purpose:

At a moment when members of society seem to be particularly coarse with one another, conveying the principle of kindness is highly relevant. Social media exacerbates the challenges of treating one another with respect and dignity, but it is not the source of the disrespect and meanness that seems all too common nowadays. This module is designed to continue the conversation on gratitude by exploring the value of kindness. It can center in the synchronous session on the interpersonal interpretation of this principle or be broadened to encapsulate a conversation of societal matters. Prompt the students to engage with one another on topics as perfunctory as road rage or impatience in a check-out line to cultural phenomena as persistent as racism or xenophobia.

Resources & Teaching Suggestions:

One way to consider kindness in its broader societal context is related to the very making of America over the centuries since its founding. Dr. William Bennett, former U.S. Secretary of Education, in his edited volume, The Book of Virtues, includes Emma Lazarus’ 1883 poem “The New Colossus” suggesting that “one of America’s great national policies” is the kindness shown to immigrants from around the world who came and continue to come to the United States to realize their dreams (Bennett, 1993, p. 179). Have your students listen to the following oral interpretation of her famous writing and, given the ongoing debate about immigration in the U.S., initiate a discussion on this policy issue in the context of kindness.

Media embedded July 19, 2020

Ted-Ed. (2019, 2 July). “New Colossus” by Emma Lazarus. [Video]. YouTube.


Among the prompts you might offer are:

  • What are the considerations that go into the development of public law on a complex issue that elicits strong opposing opinions?
  • How can lawmakers and the public engage in a civil dialogue that reflects our founding principle as a nation of laws and our heritage as a refuge for immigrants arriving from other lands?

Attitude: Perseverance

For the Learner

Too often too many of us want to give up when circumstances start to get a little challenging, when the process of growth generates a bit too much discomfort, or when others around us seem to be getting ahead by taking easier paths. Whether this character trait is called perseverance, resilience, determination, or tenacity, American history overflows with examples of individuals and teams that have pushed through difficult times to achieve goals that seemed impossible.

Perhaps one of the most important examples of perseverance was exhibited before the nation had even celebrated its second birthday, adopted the Constitution, or elected its first president. But even in the winter of 1777-1778, General George Washington and his fellow patriots were providing the leadership and resolve necessary to bring our very country to life. Watch this video to learn more about what it took for the men to survive their winter encampment at Valley Forge, Pennsylvania:

Media embedded July 19, 2020

Senator Ben Sasse. (2017, 19 December). Valley Forge: One of the first American Christmases. [Video]. YouTube.

But perseverance isn’t just a historical phenomenon; it’s something in our very midst even today. Here is a recent example of a fellow teenager who shares his story of overcoming challenges on the athletic field:

Media embedded July 19, 2020

Characterdotorg. (2020, 5 May). Ayomide. [Video]. YouTube.

Comment: After watching these two videos, make a comment on what stood out to you about the characteristic of perseverance. What does Ayomide have in common with the patriots of Valley Forge? How can we apply their lessons to our lives?

Update: Now, make an update on an experience from your life where you have had to overcome adversity through the application of perseverance. What lessons did you learn from the experience? How are you applying them to your current circumstances? In what ways might you be able to use what you’ve learned once you go to college, begin your career, or start a family?

For the Teacher

Purpose:

Perseverance is an incredibly important and relevant subject to be taught as part of the ESLP. With increasing incidence of teen anxiety, depression, and even suicide, we need to engage with our young people to reinforce – or perhaps even teach in the first place – that they should not give up, even in difficult circumstances.

Resources & Teaching Suggestions:

American and world history are replete with examples of men and women who have led their nations or people to success against overwhelming odds. Here are three examples from American and British history that you may wish to explore in greater depth with your students:

  • Pres. Abraham Lincoln – Gettysburg Address – a call for the sustained will needed to fight for liberty and equality

“It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us – that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion, that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain, that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom, and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth” (Bennett, 1993, p. 569)

  • British Prime Minister Winston Churchill – Report to Parliament after Dunkirk – a call for courage, unity, determination, and sacrifice

“We shall go on to the end…we shall defend our island, whatever the cost may be, we shall fight on the beaches, we shall fight on the landing grounds, we shall fight in the fields and in the streets, we shall fight in the hills; we shall never surrender.” (Bennett, 1993, p. 572)

  • Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. – I Have a Dream Speech – a call for Americans to live up to the promise of their founding documents

“I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: ‘We hold these truths to be self-evident; that all men are created equal.’…I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character. I have a dream today.” (Bennett, 1993, p. 575)

Attitude: Optimism

For the Learner

Another key component to attitude is adopting an optimistic approach to life. You may have heard the observation by the famous optimist, Zig Ziglar, “It is your attitude, more than your aptitude, that will determine your altitude.” More than just a cliché, this is a formula for success in your life. It takes very little effort to be a pessimist. Smile more, encourage others, believe the hard can be accomplished, and the “impossible” can be achieved.

Take a few minutes to watch the following video, which features a 17-year-old student from Venezuela, who has been in the country for only four years, taught himself English in six months, runs a company, and recently published a book. He is a terrific example of a young person who maintains an optimistic attitude and refuses to accept that anything is impossible.

Media embedded July 19, 2020

TEDx Talks (2019, 16 December). A case for more youth optimism. | Juan David Campolargo | TEDxNaperville. [Video]. YouTube.

There is a great quotation from the Navy Seabees that perfectly captures the concept of optimism, “The difficult we do now, the impossible takes a little longer” (Eng, 2018). As you go about your day, think about how you can apply this notion that success is inevitable with a good attitude!

Comment: What is your reaction to Juan David Campolargo’s TED Talk? Make a comment on your thoughts and feelings about what he presented regarding Generation Z and the future.

Update: Please post your own update on some possible actions you can take or recommend to your peers to promote a greater sense of optimism in our community.

For the Teacher

Purpose:

Optimism is viewed as a cultural strength, but many young people today are experiencing hopelessness, suggesting the need for interventions designed to promote optimism (Gillham, & Reivich, 2004). In this final ESLP module before the capstone, we move to this important subject.

Resources & Teaching Suggestions:

Optimism, enthusiasm, and positivity are keys to learning and success in general. Start some conversations during the synchronous session of this module by showing the following video and encouraging the students to share their reactions.

Media embedded July 19, 2020

Soul Pancake. (2015, 13 September). The power of optimism | Man on the street. [Video]. YouTube.

And here’s a great quote to keep in mind while facilitating this session:

“Every great and commanding moment in the annals of the world is the triumph of some enthusiasm.” –Ralph Waldo Emerson

Summative Survey

Students have now completed the six main modules of the Emerging Servant Leaders Program - self-awareness; civility; citizenship; responsibility; gratitude; and attitude. After they have completed the peer reviewed project, please administer the following survey, which will be helpful in evaluating the efficacy of this program as participants prepare for the capstone module, including the experiential learning day in the state capital.

Peer Reviewed Project

You have now completed the six main modules of the Emerging Servant Leaders Program (ESLP) – self-awareness, civility, citizenship, responsibility, gratitude, and attitude – and have the opportunity to reflect on what you’ve learned. Ultimately, the ESLP is about preparing you to be an engaged citizen who is focused on recognizing and living out your unique purpose, tending to others’ needs before your own, and being a leader who makes a meaningful contribution to society.

After the first module – self-awareness – which had three components/updates (purpose, meaning, and core values) you prepared two biographies, a current one and a future one for ten years from now. Based on what you have learned since we completed that module and exercise, take the opportunity to review your writing. Then, read the following poem, “The Bridge Builder” by Will Allen Dromgoole which reflects on how each generation has responsibilities to those that follow – in other words, what legacy we leave for others.

https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/52702/the-bridge-builder

(Dromgoole, W. A., 1931).

Now, based on your future biography and Dromgoole’s sentiments, prepare a 1-2 page paper reflecting on what you’ve learned about the character and citizenship traits we’ve explored in this program and how you plan to apply them going forward. You can choose to focus your work on any one, several, or all of the characteristics we’ve considered (self-awareness, civility, citizenship, responsibility, gratitude, and attitude).

This project will be reviewed against the following rubric by three other peers in the class, and you will have the opportunity to review three of your peers’ works.

Peer Assessment Rubric

 

Conclusion

Citizenship and character education and educational psychology is an important nexus in the Emerging Servant Leaders Program (ESLP). It is my hope that by including the subjects of responsibility, gratitude, and attitude as the more advanced modules in this program, students will be better prepared to engage in the experiential learning components of the capstone module, which follows immediately after these lessons.

It is also worth noting that the ESLP remains in development. Although I have made substantial progress in developing this curriculum in the four courses comprising the Learning Design and Leadership core of the online Ed.D. in Education Policy, Organization, and Leadership (EPOL) at the University of Illinois, there is more work to be done before it is launched. I continue to seek and welcome the perspectives of fellow scholars, researchers, and educators on this evolving project to foster greater numbers of young people prepared to accept the responsibilities of adulthood in – and offer leadership for – our representative republic in the 21st century.

References

Althof, W., & Berkowitz, M. W. (2006). Moral education and character education: Their relationship and roles in citizenship education. Journal of Moral Education, 35(4), 495-518.

Architect of the Capitol. (n.d.). About relief portrait plaques of lawgivers. Retrieved on July 18, 2020, from: https://www.aoc.gov/explore-capitol-campus/art/about-relief-portrait-plaques-lawgivers

Bennett, W. J. (Ed.). (1993). The book of virtues. New York, NY: Simon and Schuster.

Big Think. (2012, 23 April). Daniel Goleman introduces emotional intelligence. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y7m9eNoB3NU

Characterdotorg. (2020, 29 June). Kyla. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R-nDDiTvw6M&feature=emb_title

Dovilla, M. (2019a.). Emerging servant leaders: Developing America’s next generation of leaders. Retrieved from: https://cgscholar.com/bookstore/works/195437?category_id=364

Dovilla, M. (2019b). Cultivating good citizenship: A learning module for the emerging servant leaders program. Retrieved from: https://cgscholar.com/bookstore/works/201396?category_id=364

Dovilla, M. (2020). Experiential citizenship: Emerging servant leaders program capstone. Retrieved from: https://cgscholar.com/bookstore/works/207341?category_id=364

Dromgoole, W. A. (1931). The bridge builder. Poetry Foundation. Retrieved on July 18, 2020, from: https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/52702/the-bridge-builder

Eng, D. (2018, 9 July). The impossible takes a little longer. Naval History and Heritage Command. Retrieved on July 19, 2020, from: https://usnhistory.navylive.dodlive.mil/2018/07/09/the-impossible-takes-a-little-longer/

Gillham, J., & Reivich, K. (2004). Cultivating optimism in childhood and adolescence. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 591(1), 146-163.

Hoge, J. D. (2002). Character education, citizenship education, and the social studies. The social studies, 93(3), 103-108.

Horowitz, J. M. & Graf, N. (2019, February 20). Most U.S. teens see anxiety and depression as a major problem among their peers. Pew Research Center. Retrieved on July 16, 2020, from https://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2019/02/20/most-u-s-teens-see-anxiety-and-depression-as-a-major-problem-among-their-peers/

Learning to Give (n.d.). Infuse giving into academics. Retrieved on July 18, 2020 from: https://www.learningtogive.org/

National Center for Education Statistics (2018, November 15). The nation’s report card: 2014 civics. Retrieved July 16, 2020, from https://nces.ed.gov/nationsreportcard/civics/

Ohio History Central. (n.d.). Berea, Ohio. Retrieved on July 16, 2020, from: https://ohiohistorycentral.org/w/Berea,_Ohio

Presidential Leadership Scholars (2020, January 27). 2020 Class of Presidential Leadership Scholars Announced. Retrieved on July 16, 2020, from https://www.presidentialleadershipscholars.org/2020-class-of-presidential-leadership-scholars-announced/

randomactsofkindness. (2017, 13 November). The science of kindness. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O9UByLyOjBM

Sasse, B. (2017). The vanishing American adult. New York, NY: Saint Martin’s Press.

Self, J. (n.d.). Civic responsibility. Learning to give. Retrieved on July 18, 2020, from: https://www.learningtogive.org/resources/civic-responsibility

Senator Ben Sasse. (2017, 19 December). Valley Forge: One of the first American Christmases. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfx_VafeCxs

Soul Pancake. (2015, 13 September). The power of optimism | Man on the street. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pbjH9d4h6GQ

Ted-Ed. (2019, 2 July). “New Colossus” by Emma Lazarus. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NaKUuk78L1A

TEDx Talks (2019, 16 December). A case for more youth optimism. | Juan David Campolargo | TEDxNaperville. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GGyJyVt55jg

The Grindstone Institute (2020). About Grindstone. Retrieved on July 16, 2020, from https://thegrindstoneinstitute.com/about/

The School of Life. (2019, 13 November). How to test your emotional maturity. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tz7zxh9Bfow

U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. (n.d.). Citizenship rights and responsibilities. Retrieved on July 18, 2020, from https://www.uscis.gov/citizenship/learners/citizenship-rights-and-responsibilities

Wallace, J. B. (2018, 23 February). How to raise more grateful children. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved on July 19, 2020, from: https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-to-raise-more-grateful-children-1519398748

Washington Post. (2018, 21 November). A Thanksgiving message from Teddy Roosevelt — and Post opinions. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5sgAvkfos7I