Produced with Scholar
Icon for Analyzing Numerical Data

Analyzing Numerical Data

Learning Module

Abstract

This learning module is the first unit in a senior level course entitled Advanced Mathematical Decision Making. Its purpose is to highlight how mathematics is used in real life. Students are asked to collect data and use it to draw conclusions.

Overview

This learning module is called analyzing numerical data. It comes from a course that I currently teach called Advanced Mathematical Decision Making. I am adapting the course material into a learning module format. In this class, students generally work collaboratively to solve problems that are open ended and grounded in real world experience.

This learning module relates to several of the large ideas of this course. Much of the learning takes place in a collaborative and hands-on learning environment. Students are frequently given a problem or scenario and asked to discuss, brainstorm, estimate, collect data, make assumptions, and try different methods until reaching an acceptable result. I think that these modes of learning most align with the ideas of social cognition, situated cognition and productive struggle. Collins et al. (1988) indicate that situated cognition knowledge is built through experience and context. So experiencing a problem and then thinking about and experiencing different facets of that problem help to build deeper understanding of concepts. Brown et al. (1989) discuss that learning is social in nature and deep learning and understanding are a result of students building a shared experience of interacting and problem solving together. Productive struggle is another important component to the content in this learning module. Some of the activities present problems that can be grappled with and solved in many different ways. The goal is for students to deeply engage in mathematical problem solving and develop a sense of accomplishment for persevering through complex problems. This is not a learning model built on direct instruction, but instead active engagement and interaction with peers and content. Capon and Kuhn (2004) suggest that for students to make meaning of mathematical ideas, they must actively engage in them and form thoughts, conjectures, and ideas of their own rather than memorize material to replicate in a similar context (Capon & Kuhn, 2004).

 

Intended Learning Outcomes

Student

Have you ever wondered…

...how many people were present at a crowded event, like a concert?

...how many tennis balls it would take to fill a room?

... why those black bars appear on your tv when you watch an old movie?

...how to calculate the grade you need on a final to get the grade you want in a class?

...the purpose of the barcodes on things you buy?

 

All of these things related to the big topics of our unit: ratio and weighted sums! You have studied ratios before, but this unit will hopefully provide you with some practical applications of these concepts. At the end of this unit, you will be able to use ratios and weighted sums to estimate large numbers based on data, calculate aspect ratio of screens, calculate final averages, and learn what is meant by a “check digit.” You will do this by making estimations, working with other students, listening to the ideas of others, and drawing conclusions based on your thinking and data.

 

We will be utilizing the standards for mathematical practice listed below:

CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP1 Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them.

CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP2 Reason abstractly and quantitatively.

CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP3 Construct viable arguments and critique the reasoning of others.

CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP4 Model with mathematics.

CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP5 Use appropriate tools strategically.

CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP6 Attend to precision.

CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP7 Look for and make use of structure.

CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP8 Look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning.

 

Teacher

This learning module is the first unit in a senior level course designed as a 4th year math course for students. The prerequisite is Algebra 2. Is it designed to help students see the real world applications of the mathematics they have learned throughout their schooling. Students generally learn about ratios and means in middle school, but may not have been ready to learn some of their more advanced applications. This unit’s goal is to provide real world examples of these ideas.

 

Not only will students model and apply the ideas of ratio and weighted averages, but they will do so in a collaborative environment. Students will often work with one another to brainstorm ideas, present their ideas, critique the ideas of others, and showcase their learning in a project to end the unit.

These lessons are part of a larger unit that takes 4 weeks of instructional time.

The following materials will be needed:

  • Tennis balls
  • Boxes
  • Objects with UPC codes

 

Update 1: Estimating Crowds

Student

Content Goal: Estimate the size of a crowd at an event using ratio and proportion. 

Social Goal: CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP1 Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them.

Wrubel, S. (2013). [Lollapalooza crowd] [Photgraph]. Chicago Magazine. https://www.chicagomag.com/Chicago-Magazine/The-Escape-Artist/July-2013/Heres-Where-to-Stay-During-Lollapalooza/

Estimating the number of people in a large crowd (for example, watching a parade or
attending/marching in a political rally) is quite challenging and often leads to controversies.
One method sometimes used is to focus on a small section of the crowd, such as a
rectangular area.

Here is a link to the notesheet for today. 

Media embedded July 15, 2020

Los Angeles Times. (2019, August 18). Rally at Victoria Park in Hong Kong attracts hundreds of thousands. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DLH3SU3KXks&feature=emb_logo

Comment: Watch the video above about protestors in Victoria Park, Hong Kong and write a comment on the numerical discrepancy. Comment on two of your peers' responses.

Update: Here is a photo of Victoria Park in Hong Kong. Use the measure distance feature of google maps to estimate the size of the crowd at the protest in the video. You may need to watch the video again to decide what to measure. Explain/show your methods. Was your estimate closer to the protestors estimate or the police department's estimate? Comment on 2 of your peers' updates. How does their estimate compare to yours? How do their methods compare to yours?

Google. (n.d.). [Victoria Park, Hong Kong]. Retrieved July 18, 2020, from https://www.google.com/maps/d/u/0/viewer?msa=0&hl=en&ie=UTF8&t=m&z=18&source=embed&mid=10yp_vzcJLvamX3AvSQkzUAwI2EM&ll=22.28191303399474%2C114.18899781228853
 

Teacher

Background: Students will be collecting data on how many people fit in a specified space and then using that data to esimate the size of a large crowd. To prep for today's lesson. Use painter's tape or masking tape to create a 5 ft by 5ft square somewhere in the classroom. 

 

Opener: Display the picture of the large crowd. Ask them to share their experience of being in a large crowd. Explain that today, you will be estimating crowd size. 

Notes: Begin question 1 together as a class, and explain that you will be collecting data as a class to estimate the size of crowds. Before calling up volunteers, you may have a discussion about how close together the "crowd" you are making will be - mosh pit close? comfortably close? Make a decision as a class about this. This will assist in a future discussion about making assumptions to solve problems. Ask for volunteers to stand in the 5 by 5 foot square you have made. 

Questions 1-3 are designed to be done in groups. Emphasize the importance of perseverance and collaboration. Student may want to you tell them the answer or how to do it, but it will be more useful for them if they have to reason the problem with their group. 

Circulate the room asking probing questions about the work that students are doing. Take note of the different methods that students are doing, and ask some groups to present their methods to the class. Emphasize the importance of listening to the contributions of others. 

Closure: End class with the video of the protest in Hong Kong. Lead a short discussion about the discrepancy in crowd size that is shown in the video.  

Update 2: How many tennis balls?

Student

Content Goal: Estimate the number of tennis balls that can fill the classroom using volume, ratio and proportion.

Social Goal: CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP5 Use appropriate tools strategically.

Think for a moment about how many tennis balls it would take to fill our classroom. 

Phelan, J. (2011). [Come up to my room][Photograph]. Recycle Nation. https://recyclenation.com/2011/04/ten-tennis-ball-recycle-furniture-designs/

Here is the link for today's notes

Comment: What assumptions (or simplifications) did you make to build your estimate? Comment on at least 2 peers' responses. 

Update: Choose either another space or another type of ball to make an estimate for how many are needed to fill a given space. Show your method and calculations. What assumptions did you have to make for your example? Comment on at least 2 other peers' updates.

 

 

Teacher

Background: Students will be estimating how many tennis balls it takes to fill the classroom. They will need knowledge of volume for this task, which they have enountered in middle school. You will need tennis balls and boxes (preferably enough for each group to make an estimate).  One method is to fill a box and use that to extrapolate how many tennis balls it would take to fill the room. If you do not have that many tennis balls, use what you have to collect data as a class. Then let students make their estimates in their groups. It is not advisable to make a class estimation, as that may allow students to rely on the thinking of too many other students. Working in a group towards a common answer will help all group members to contribute. You will also then be able to compare the solutions that all groups came up with. 

Opener: Ask students to make a quick estimate for how many tennis balls it takes to fill the classroom. Give them 60 seconds. 

Notes: Direct students to the notesheet and have them begin to collect data to determine how many tennis balls would be needed to fill the room. If they ask you about assumptions, let the group make their own assumptions (are they assuming the room is empty? is the classroom a perfect rectangle? , etc.)and have them document any assumptions they made. 

As students work, circulate and take note of different methods that students are using. Have groups present their solutions to the class. Encourage the class to ask the presenters questions about their work and methods. Ask the class about similarities and differences between methods that groups use. 

Closure: Ask students to individually write about their preferred method for solving these types of problems. 

 

Update 3: Ratios in the Media

Student

Content Goal: Use ratios and proportional reasoning to solve problems about screens and screen size. 

Social Goal: CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP1 Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them.

Media embedded July 16, 2020

Gonçalves, D. [Now you see it]. (2015, September 5). Aspect Ratio: Which Should You Choose? [Video]. Youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R26_F7pecqo

Here is the link to the notes

Comment: Write about a time when you have encountered aspect ratio. What type of device were you using? What type of media were you trying to view? Was the media created for the device you were using? Was the device an older device? a new device? Comment on at least 2 peers' responses.

Update: Create an update that explains what aspect ratio is to someone who is not familiar with it. Include at least 2 images to illustrate your point. Comment on at least 2 peers' updates. 

Teacher

Background: Students will be using aspect ratio to calculate the length and width of different types of screens. They will need to recall Pythagorean Theorem for this calculation, as the diagonal of a screen creates the hypotenuse of a right triangle. Pythagoerean Theorem is a major topic of geometry and middle school, so students should have some knowledge of it. 

Opener: Ask students to name the different types of screens that they deal with (phones, tv, chromebooks, calculators, etc.). If there is a screen in the classroom, measure it as a class to show students that the measurement comes from the diagonal, not the length and width of the screen (e.g. a 48 inch television is called that because of the length of its diagonal.). Ask students if they have ever noticed the black bars when watching a movie or dvd on television. Indicate that all of this has to do with aspect ratio. 

Notes: Direct students to the notesheet. Students will be able to figure out question 2 because of its nicer numbers, but may struggle for a method on number 3. Encourage them to share and present ideas to come up with a class method. Students will then use aspect ratio to answer a series of questions. Ask probing questions and listen to students discussions to highlight some things for closure. 

Closure: Highlight some of the good conversations you heard as you circulated the room. Praise the collaboration and praise the perseverance students showed on question 3.  Praise the effort you are seeing in your students.  

Update 4: Final Grade Averages

Student

Content Goal: Use the concept of weighted sums to calculate grades. 

Social Goal: CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP7 Look for and make use of structure.

Media embedded July 16, 2020

Mathispower4u. (2012, October 31). Ex: Find a Course Percentage and Grade Using a Weighted Average. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P0oinC6ejFI

Here is the link to the notes

Comment: What would be your ideal grading system? Explain why you chose the weights you did. Comment on at least 2 peers' responses. 

Teacher

Background: This section is about calculating grade averages. The next 2 lessons use the idea of weights to calculate different numbers. Calculating grade averages is something that many students may appreciate knowing how to do, especially for any post-secondary schooling they may do. Although the idea of averages may seem like a simple one to many students, its applications can be far reaching and complex. 

Opener: Ask students if they know about the grade breakdown of this course (i.e. what percentage of the grade is made up of tests? projects? homework? classrwork? etc.). 

Notes: Direct students to the note sheet. Circulate the room and encourage students to check answers with one another to ensure accuracy. Students will have to either use algebra, work backwards, or guess and check on question 5. Encourage multiple methods and have students present their methods to showcase the different ways to solve these problems. 

Closure: Ask students to think about what their ideal grade weighting system would be. Have them share their ideas with a partner.

Update 5: Universal Product Codes

Student

Content Goal: Learn to compute the check digit of a Universal Product Code using weighted sums.

Social Goal: CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP8 Look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning.

Media embedded July 16, 2020

 

Half as interesting. (2017, November 2). How to read barcodes. [Video]. Youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XPuTZMp-HE8

Here is the link to the notes

Comment: In what ways is the UPC check digit calculation like the activities you explored in previous sections?

Update: Research another type of standardized bar code (for example VIN numbers, credit card numbers, ISBNs, etc.). How are these numbers significant? How do these numbers use a check digit? How are they designed to catch errors?

Teacher

Background: Students will be calculating the check digit on UPC codes using weighted averages. You will need several products with UPCs on them. Encourage students to take out products with barcodes they might have with them (pop bottles, single use water bottles, binders, folders, etc.). They can verify the check digit on these items. 

Opener: Ask students if they know anything about the barcodes listed on items they purchase. Some students might have experience with scanning barcodes because of jobs they have. Ask them to share their experience about this (i.e. what happens if the bar code isn't scanning, or if computers are down, etc.).

Notes: Direct students to the note sheet. Ensure that they understand the alternating nature of the weights (i.e. that every other number will be multiplied by 3).  Encourage students to check their work with one another. 

Closure: Give students a UPC code and ask them to calculate the correct check digit. Have them write their work and answer on an index card and turn it in. 

Update 6: Fermi Questions

Student

Content Goal: Create, research, and answer a fermi question.

Social Goal: CCSS.MATH.PRACTICE.MP1 Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them.

We looked at Fermi Questions when we estimated the number of tennis balls needed to fill a room. The video below is a refresher on Fermi questions. You will create a project to show what you have learned about making estimations by using a Fermi question of your choosing. 

Media embedded July 17, 2020

Mitchell, M. (2012, September 12). A clever way to estimate enormous numbers - Michael Mitchell. Ted-Ed. [Video]. Youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YzvupOX8Is&feature=youtu.be

Create a work: Here is the link to the project information and rubric. Be sure that you include all necessary components because your work will be reviewed by your peers. You will then make any adjustments necessary before submitting your final product. 

After you have completed your project, complete this unit survey.

Teacher

Background: This is the project for the unit on Fermi Questions. Students will create a Fermi question to answer, create assumptions to help answer their question, research any necessary information, and calculate their answer. 

Opener: Ask students to share with a partner what some of the main ideas were for the crowd size calculations or the tennis ball challenge. They should come up with some ideas around ratios and/or proportional reasoning. 

Notes: Have students watch the Fermi question video. Explain the project and go through the rubric with students. Encourage students to be creative with their Fermi questions. (Note: they do not have to use the method in the video to answer their Fermi questions.) Give students time to work on their projects and assist as needed. Student may need assistance creating a quetion and making assumptions to help answer that question. 

Closure: Remind students that their project will be peer reviewed based on the rubric provided. Encouarge them to read through each piece of the rubric before submitted their work. 

References

Brown, J. S., Collins, A., & Duguid, P. (1989). Situated cognition and the culture of learning. Educational researcher, 18(1), 32-42.

Charles A. Dana Center. (2010). Advanced mathematical decision making. University of Texas at Austin.

Collins, A., Brown, J. S., & Newman, S. E. (1988). Cognitive apprenticeship: Teaching the craft of reading, writing and mathematics. Thinking: The Journal of Philosophy for Children, 8(1), 2-10.

Gonçalves, D. [Now you see it]. (2015, September 5). Aspect Ratio: Which Should You Choose? [Video]. Youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R26_F7pecqo

Google. (n.d.). [Victoria Park, Hong Kong]. Retrieved July 18, 2020, from https://www.google.com/maps/d/u/0/viewer?msa=0&hl=en&ie=UTF8&t=m&z=18&source=embed&mid=10yp_vzcJLvamX3AvSQkzUAwI2EM&ll=22.28191303399474%2C114.18899781228853

Half as interesting. (2017, November 2). How to read barcodes. [Video]. Youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XPuTZMp-HE8

Los Angeles Times. (2019, August 18). Rally at Victoria Park in Hong Kong attracts hundreds of thousands. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DLH3SU3KXks&feature=emb_logo

Mathispower4u. (2012, October 31). Ex: Find a Course Percentage and Grade Using a Weighted Average. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P0oinC6ejFI

Mitchell, M. (2012, September 12). A clever way to estimate enormous numbers - Michael Mitchell. Ted-Ed. [Video]. Youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YzvupOX8Is&feature=youtu.be

National Governors Association Center for Best Practices and Council of Chief State School Officers (NGA Center and CCSSO). Common Core State Standards for Mathematics. Standards for Mathematical Practice. Washington, D.C.: NGA Center and CCSSO, 2010. http://www.corestandards.org/Math/Practice/

Phelan, J. (2011). [Come up to my room][Photograph]. Recycle Nation. https://recyclenation.com/2011/04/ten-tennis-ball-recycle-furniture-designs/ 

Wrubel, S. (2013). [Lollapalooza crowd] [Photgraph]. Chicago Magazine. https://www.chicagomag.com/Chicago-Magazine/The-Escape-Artist/July-2013/Heres-Where-to-Stay-During-Lollapalooza/